Monday Night at NCTM: Poster Session and Kenneth Zeichner's Plenary Address

Braving the snow, Ryan Grover and I slogged our way via RTD from Snowy Boulder to Almost-as-Snowy Denver. We arrived in time for a poster session. If you're unfamiliar with poster sessions, I'd describe them as a sort of academic mingling punctuated by awkward moments of silence as you read people's posters before deciding if the person is worth talking to. Yes, it's as fun as it sounds. I had one extended conversation with Sara Lohrman Hartman from Ohio University. Her recent dissertation work in rural Appalachia studied how a small school utilized a math coach. That's a rare luxury for a small rural school, at least in my limited experience.

As 7:00 neared I made my way to the plenary session and happily found Amanda Jansen standing outside the door. I'd never met Amanda in person, but I've conversed with her regularly on Google+ for more than a year. In that time she's made time for me and put up with my questions and rambling; it may not mean much to her, but as a grad student it means a lot to be welcomed by others in the field. We took some seats midway back in the room and settled in for a talk from Kenneth Zeichner, a well-known expert in the field of teacher education. His talk was not specific to mathematics education, but still of great interest for anyone who cares about how teachers are prepared and the institutions that prepare them.

My horrible picture of Ken Zeichner

As a student in Jennie Whitcomb and Dan Liston's Research on Teaching and Teacher Education class this semester, Ken's talk was very familiar. (If you've ever been told of the importance of reflective teaching, Ken and Dan literally wrote the book on the subject.) Ken began by framing three perspectives in the current debate about teacher education. First are the defenders, those who want to preserve the function and status of college and university-based teacher education (UBTE). Next are the reformers, those who seek to deregulate teaching and let the quality of teachers and teacher preparation be dictated by free market principles. Ken frequently cited Rick Hess as a proponent of this perspective, and shared George Will's belief that closing ed schools was the surest path to improving education in the U.S. Last are the transformers. This group, and where Ken places himself, wants reform of teacher education, but in a way that builds upon the capacity and expertise of UBTE and preserves a democratic, public system not driven by market forces.

From here, Ken shared what he sees as the two visions for preparing quality teachers. One is a system that produces professionals for a teaching profession; the other is a system that is technocratic and highly skill-driven, with teachers focused on actions that raise test scores in a narrow curriculum. Teaching skill is important, admits Zeichner, but professionals go beyond the management of a classroom to understand the social and political context of schools and their communities, and have skills that allow them to better reflect in ways that positively impact their teaching.

There are about 3.6 million teachers in the U.S., and alternative pathways for training those teachers (TFA, teacher residency programs, etc.) have grown since the early 1990s. Still, somewhere between 70-80% of the nation's teachers have earned licensure through UBTE at one of the almost 1400 college- and university-based programs around the country. Even if we were to deregulate teacher education, the market does not (and probably would not) have the capacity to prepare teachers without the help of UBTE.

Zeichner admits that UBTE has gotten a lot of non-critical, negative attention from the media. We've come to believe that too many teachers are not getting good results and efforts are now underway to trace poor student results back to the programs that prepared the teacher in those classrooms. When a recent bridge collapsed, said Zeichner, "The engineer who designed the bridge was exposed in the media but I don't remember anyone asking what engineering school he attended." Using another analogy, Zeichner said judging teacher education this way was similar to the idea that we should judge medical schools by patient outcomes. The result, says Zeichner, would be doctors avoiding treating those who need treatment most, just as teachers will avoid teaching in the tough schools with histories of poor test scores. This will lead to further inequality in how quality teachers are distributed, something the U.S. -- which was recently ranked 26th out of 29 nations in a UN report about child well-being -- cannot afford to have happen. The reformers' cries of "No Excuses!" does not rid us of the ails of poverty, no matter how good the teachers might be.

Zeichner addressed some key contradictions in the teacher education argument. For example, the Obama administration has pushed for higher standards for students while simultaneously pushing for alternative pathways to teaching that have lower standards. Also, as Mike Rose has pointed out, the logic of removing teacher education requirements and regulation, or to disregard teaching experience as a measure of quality, makes little to no sense in any other field. (Nobody would trust a neurosurgeon who hadn't been properly trained and lacked experience.) Further, no high-achieving country has deregulated their system of teacher education. Countries like Finland and South Korea have set their standards high, not lowered them.

Zeichner admits that messages like this, and his affiliation with schools of education, have led many to see him as a defender of UBTE. Zeichner insists that he's not a defender, but a transformer. Instead of deregulating UBTE, he sees a great need to change, yet not replace, our current system. This transformation would shift UBTE closer to the world of practice, providing a clinical experience for preservice teachers in a hybrid approach. This move would require the sharing of responsibility and accountability for teacher preparation with schools and their communities, a shared space with values that would prioritize democratized knowledge. Zeichner never advocated for this as a cure-all, but it is the approach most likely to support a system of effective, professionally prepared teachers.

Q&A

(Note: These quotes from Zeichner are rough approximations. Caveat emptor.)

Q: An attendee from Chicago asked about the dismantling of public education in Chicago and the closing of public schools in lieu of charters.

Zeichner: "I'm not against charter schools. I'm against disempowerment of parents and local stakeholders." Zeichner says he was seeing similar school closings in his home of Philladelphia, where public schools are being closed and replaced by charters run by charter management operators. A new study should be out soon that shows the ineffectiveness of these approaches so far. "There's a lack of democratic debate. I'm not for the alternatives to go away, but I'm for an honest debate."

Q: Why do educational entrepreneurs think they're going to make a lot of money?
A: Zeichner: "Some alternative routes use non-profit status for the tax breaks and they outsource their services. From a distance it's hard to see where they're making money, but they are. ... I'm not implying anything about morality. Greedy, self-serving attitudes are everywhere, including universities. But there is a lack of transparency about what's going on. It astounds me how the NewSchools Venture Fund has so much influence while flying under the radar."

Q: I've done UBTE and "quick fix" teacher education programs. Quick fix doesn't work, and online programs are dangerous. Still, too many teachers don't really their profession like a true profession.
A: Zeichner defends online education to a degree, having been involved with some online programs that offered a lot of quality. "I'd be careful in discounting all online programs. Some universities are using them along with more traditional approaches. They can be improved and we still have a lot to learn. We need to be careful about demonizing anything just based on their sponsorships or affiliations."

Q: What are things a new generation of mathematics educators should fight for in public education? How do we take our conversations outside the education community?
Zeichner: "For me, I've decided that ed schools alone will not accomplish much. The ownership of teacher education needs to be broader and shared with communities. I recently met with a lot of stakeholders and listened to their stories. There's a lot of community activism in places like Chicago and Philadelphia, and we can join those efforts already underway instead of coming in from above with solutions to their problems. I wish I'd been more in the public sphere in my career, writing more op-eds and participating in forums, even if many would have disagreed with me. Now, the polarization we're left with is harmful."

Q: How do we measure low-performing teacher education programs?
Zeichner: "I agree with the National Research Council's report on improving teacher education, and that the profession itself needs to take care of its own accreditation and monitoring. I'm afraid that test scores and value-added models will fill this role at great cost and distraction, as simply ranking as a way to improve quality has never really worked. To anoint these people who know little about the field as saviors is idiocy. Twenty-five years from now people will look back and wonder how we could have been so stupid."

(Mic drop. Not really, but I wish.)

My Thoughts

For me, Zeichner's serious (and some might say somewhat depressing) talk was balanced by a sense of validation. Not only did I recently write a paper that expressed many of these same ideas, it gives me hope that the system I'm a part of is recognizing a need and possibility for significant change. For some people, I'm sure a reformed/deregulated system of teacher education seems like a remote possibility, but right now in Colorado we're anticipating the introduction of legislation proposing to do exactly that, removing the requirement for teacher education as we know it. If that bill appears and makes progress, you'll be sure to hear more from me.

Planning for NCTM 2013

It's going to be a busy, busy week. The advantage of having a major conference in your backyard is that you feel like you can go to everything, but the disadvantage is the feeling you should be going to everything despite local distractions and responsibilities that don't go away. I try to get my money's worth at conferences; I think when I went to the Annual Meeting in 2008 in Salt Lake City I attended 17 sessions across the four days. We'll see if I set a new personal record this year. I'll be attending both the Research Presession and the Annual Meeting and have attempted to describe my schedule below.

RME at NCTM

Before getting into what I hope to attend, there are a number of opportunities to learn about Realistic Mathematics Education at this year's conference. I don't have a definitive list, but these are the RME-related sessions I'm aware of:

Tuesday


1:00 - Marja van den Heuvel-Panhuizen, Marc van Zanten, et al (Room 103, Colorado Convention Center)
Mathematics Curriculum Design and Development in the East and West

4:45 - +Fred Peck (Lobby A, Colorado Convention Center)
How Do Students Reinvent Their Mathematics? A Study Involving Slope

Thursday


2:45 - Mieke Abels, +Michael Matassa Jr., & +Raymond Johnson (Mile High 3 A, Convention Center)
Making Sense of Algebra with Realistic Mathematics Education

2:45 - +David Webb (Centennial Ballroom G/H, Hyatt Regency)
Promoting Student Reasoning and Understanding by Using Representational Pathways

(Putting Mieke and David head-to-head in the schedule was not something we RME folks wanted, but that's the way it is.)

Friday


12:30 - +Ryan Grover (702, Convention Center)
lim_{calculus → RME} f(calculus) = :-D

Saturday


10:00 - Britannica Digital Learning (Exhibitor Workshop, 304, Convention Center)
Meeting the Practice Standards with Models from Math in Context



My Schedule

(Yes, I overschedule. It's good practice for when sessions are full, get cancelled, or when you just can't decide.)

Monday

5:30 - Jacqueline G Van Schooneveld (Lobby A, Colorado Convention Center)
Lesson Plan Evaluation Instrument: Assessing Math Lesson Plans

5:30 - Janet Mercado, Rossella Santagata, & Sonja Mohr (Lobby A, Colorado Convention Center)
Mathematics Knowledge and Beliefs and Their Relationships in Preservice Teachers

7:00 - Kenneth Zeichner (Rooms 205/207, Colorado Convention Center)
The Struggle for the Soul of Teaching and Teacher Education

Tuesday

8:30 - Anne Foegen, Barbara J. Dougherty, Vickie L. Spain, Jeannette R. Olson, and Subha Singamaneni (Room 107/109, Colorado Convention Center)
Building Progress Monitoring Measures for Algebra: Exploring Items and Scores

10:30 - I'll be planning for one of my presentations on Thursday, but if I weren't I'd probably be headed to Interactive Paper Session 9 (for papers here, here, and here) or Jere Confrey's session.

1:00 - Alison Castro Superfine, James Lynn, Timothy M. Stoelinga, Mara V. Martinez, Cynthia L. Schneider, and Diane J. Briars (Room 205/207, Colorado Convention Center)
Supporting Underprepared Algebra Students: Results from a Design-Based Research Program

1:00 - +Douglas Clements, Julie Sarama, Curtis Tatsuoka, Kikumi Tatsuoka, and Elvira Khasanova (Room 107/109, Colorado Convention Center)
Using Learning Trajectories to Create Cognitively Diagnostic Adaptive Assessments

3:00 - Dawn Berk, James Hiebert, +Amanda Jansen, Anne Morris, Laura Cline, Heather Gallivan, Erin Meikle, and Emily Miller (Room 102, Colorado Convention Center)
Effects of Mathematics Teacher Preparation on Teacher Knowledge and Practice

3:00 - +Pat Herbst, Daniel Chazan, +Karl Kosko, +wendy rose aaron, Justin Dimmel, Orly Buchbinder, and Ander W. Erickson (Room 104, Colorado Convention Center)

4:45 - +Fred Peck (Lobby A, Colorado Convention Center)
How Do Students Reinvent Their Mathematics? A Study Involving Slope

4:45 - +Edd Taylor and Tracey E. Dobie (Lobby A, Colorado Convention Center)
Religious Engagement and Context in Mathematical Problem Solving

4:45 - Corey Webel (Lobby A, Colorado Convention Center)
Secondary Mathematics Teachers Negotiating Obligations and Goals: Two Case Studies

4:45 - +Janine Remillard, Jacqueline G. Van Schooneveld, and Enakshi Bose (Lobby A, Colorado Convention Center)
Teacher Adaptations of Homework: A Window into Curriculum Enactment

4:45 - Sara Lohrman Hartman (Lobby A, Colorado Convention Center)
Rural School Math Coaching: Lessons from a Yearlong Case Study

Wednesday

8:30 - Geoffrey Saxe, Maryl Gearhart, Ronli Diakow, Nicole Leveille Buchanan, Jennifer Collett, Bona Kang, Kenton De Kirby, and Marie Le (Rooms 205/207, Colorado Convention Center)
Engagement in Mathematical Discussion: Linking Practices and Outcomes

10:30 - +Jo Boaler (Rooms 205/207, Colorado Convention Center)
Using Research to Make a Difference

1:00 - +Janine Remillard, Ok-Kyeong Kim, Luke Reinke, Napthalin A. Atanga, Joshua Taton, Dustin O. Smith, Hendrik Van Steenbrugge, and Shari Lewis (Room 105, Colorado Convention Center)
Using Curriculum Materials to Design and Enact instruction

3:00 - Interactive Paper Session 22 (papers here, here, and here, Room 110/112, Colorado Convention Center)

5:30 - Mayim Bialik (Bellco Theater, Convention Center)
The Power of Just One Teacher

Thursday

(If you can't find good sessions on Thursday, I'm pretty sure you're at the wrong conference. I wish I could be in multiple places at once!)

8:00 - +Douglas Clements and Julie Sarama (Capitol Ballroom 4, Hyatt Regency)
Math Lessons from Research

8:00 - Daniel Chazan, Mark Driscoll, and Megan Franke (Mile High 1 C/D, Convention Center)
Teaching and Learning of Algebraic Thinking: Research Insights

9:30 - Daniel Chazan (207, Convention Center)
Algebraic Thinking When Solving Equations and Doing Word Problems

10:30 - I'll be using this for last-minute planning for my afternoon sessions. If you think you might be interested in graduate studies in mathematics education, I'd recommend the 11:30 talk from +Amy Ellis, +Anita Wager, and Eric Knuth in 704/706 of the Convention Center.

12:30 - +Alan Schoenfeld (Four Seasons 2/3, Convention Center)
Meeting the Challenges of the Common Core Standards
(I'm sure I'll miss this one, but I hope it's on MathRecap.)

1:00 - +Raymond Johnson and +Susan Thomas (Mineral Hall D/E, Hyatt Regency)
Statistical Reasoning in the Middle School

2:45 - +Mieke Abels, +Michael Matassa Jr., and +Raymond Johnson (Mile High 3A, Convention Center)
Making Sense of Algebra with Realistic Mathematics Education

Friday

8:00 - Doug Sovde (Four Seasons 1, Convention Center)
PARCC: An Interactive Progress Update

9:30 - Steven Leinwand (Four Seasons 1, Convention Center)
Essential Mindsets for Tilling the Soil for the Common Core

11:00 - Emily Thrasher and Ayanna Franklyn (605, Convention Center)
Supporting Beginning Teachers through Online Social Communities

11:30 - Mark Ellis, Chris Stapel, and Cynthia A. Miller (704/706, Convention Center)
International Perspectives on Preparing Mathematics Teachers

12:30 - Kichoon Yang (Mile High 1 C/D, Convention Center)
NCTM Business Meeting

12:30 - +Ryan Grover (702, Convention Center)
lim_{calculus → RME} f(calculus) = :-D

2:00 - Matthew R. Larson (Mile High 1 C/D, Convention Center)
Implementing the Common Core State Standards: Five Paradigm Shifts

2:00 - Christian Hirsch (203, Convention Center)
Mathematical Modeling: The Core of the Common Core State Standards

2:45 - Heather Howell, Barbara Weren, and Shona Ruiz Diaz (110/112, Convention Center)
Mathematical Knowledge for Teaching Measures as Opportunities for Professional Learning

2:45 - NCTM Professional Development Services Committee (603, Convention Center)
Building Mathematics Learning Communities with NCTM Reflection Guides

3:30 - Francis Skip Fennell, John Wray, and Beth Kobett (Four Seasons 2/3, Convention Center)
Math Specialists Get Ready Now: Common Core Assessments Are Coming

Saturday

8:00 - Zalman Usiskin (Four Seasons 2/3, Convention Center)
Mathematical Understanding in the Common Core Standards

9:30 - Frank K. Lester (Mile High 1 C/D, Convention Center)
Whatever Happened to Problem Solving in the Math Curriculum?

9:45 - Cheryl Fricchione and Diane Austin (607, Convention Center)
An Invitation to Experience Online Lesson Study Firsthand

11:00 - +Dan Meyer (Four Seasons 1, Convention Center)
Tools and Technology for Modern Math Teaching

11:30 - Patrick Scott and Ann Lawrence (607, Convention Center)
Lessons from the U.S. National Presentation at ICME-12 in Korea

12:30 - Vi Hart and George Hart (Four Seasons 2/3, Convention Center)
Viral Math Videos: A Hart-to-Hart Conversation

Reminder: You can catch some of what you might miss at MathRecap, and if you're attending the conference I encourage you to contribute!

RYSK: Skemp's Relational Understanding and Instrumental Understanding (1976)

This is the 19th in a series describing "Research You Should Know" (RYSK).

This classic think piece from Richard Skemp, despite being now almost 40 years old, still gets a great deal of attention amongst mathematics educators. I'd somehow missed it in my own preparation, which I find surprising how much I've spent studying the math wars. Skemp describes two perspectives on understanding mathematics, one which he calls relational and the other he describes as instrumental. Relational understanding is related to what we might think of a "deeper" understanding, something that reflects how and why mathematics works and is applied. Instrumental understanding relates to those reliable and typically efficient procedures we apply to produce mathematically correct answers. The part of Skemp's article that really sticks out for me is his suggestion that "mathematics" might be used too broadly: "I used to think that maths teachers were all teaching the same subject, some doing it better than others. I now believe that there are two effectively different subjects being taught under the same name, 'mathematics'" (p. 91)

Today +Chris Robinson, +Joshua Fisher, +Nat Banting, +Nik Doran, and I (pictured left-to-right along the bottom) met via Google+ Hangout to discuss Skemp's article. We discussed examples of each kind of understanding, whether one is a subset or prerequisite to the other, and the various influences that lead us to emphasize one over the other, such as curriculum and assessment.


(Some research needs to be summarized, while some needs to be expanded on. That's my explanation for why it will likely take you longer to watch the video than to read the original article.)

I've been in discussions like this before and I always find them to be fascinating. Still, it seems difficult to really get at the root: What is mathematics, and how can and should our beliefs about mathematics change? There are also strong implications for curriculum design and learning theory, as finding the right balance in our approach to both kinds of understanding should lead to better student outcomes.

References


Skemp, R. R. (1976/2006). Relational understanding and instrumental understanding. Mathematics Teaching in the Middle School, 12(2), 88–95. Originally published in Mathematics Teaching. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/41182357

Upcoming Hangout to discuss Skemp's Relational Understanding and Instrumental Understanding (1976)

Few things brighten my day more than seeing math teachers on social media seek out research:


Thanks to +Bryan Meyer, I quickly got pulled into this conversation. Together we decided to meet via Google+ Hangout this Sunday at 19:00 UTC (3 pm ET, noon PT) to talk about a classic article in mathematics education, Skemp's Relational Understanding and Instrumental Understanding, originally published in 1976 in Mathematics Teaching. If all goes according to schedule, I'll be joined by +Chris Robinson, +Nat Banting, +Nik Doran, +Bryan Meyer, and perhaps some others in our 10-person Hangout. If you'd like to join us (which means you need to have read the article), keep your eye on my Google+ posts for the event invitation. I'll probably reshare it to the Mathematics Education Research and Mathematics Education (K-12) communities. If more than 10 show an interest, I think we'll just organize multiple Hangouts...somehow. Stay tuned to the invite on Sunday and be prepared to keep your options open.

Getting the Article

In my ideal world, research would be published via open access, and I could simply link to a copy of any article I wished to share. We don't totally live in that world (yet), but thanks to JSTOR's "Register and Read" program, a lot more research is open to the public. If you follow this link to a 2006 reprint of Skemp's article, you should be able to register or log into your JSTOR account and select the article to be placed on your virtual shelf. There are restrictions -- you can't download the article, the article must remain on your shelf for at least 14 days, and you can only have three articles on your shelf at once.

If none of this works for you, you're on your own.

Update (2013-04-07): The video and wrap-up of the Hangout is here: http://blog.mathed.net/2013/04/rysk-skemps-relational-understanding.html.

Common Core Conundrum: Absolute Value

I should begin by first disclaiming that while I'm generally pro-standards, I'm also somewhat agnostic about standards. How can that be? Without going into much detail, I believe (a) what we "count" as mathematics is socially determined and standards documents are just part of that determination, (b) I will never perfectly agree with a standards document, but the amount of agreement should not be underestimated, and (c) if there's any power to standards, it's in how they're implemented -- and "good implementation" is very likely to be seen as just "good teaching" under a different set of standards, or no standards at all. It is with this mindset that I watch with some amusement (and sometimes, disappointment) arguments against the Common Core State Standards because of some poorly designed accountability measure. I'm pretty sure poorly designed accountability measures would be a concern right now regardless of the standards in place.

Still, I occasionally see things in the Common Core math standards (CCSSM) that make me stop and wonder, "How are teachers going to deal with this?" One recent instance of that was with how the CCSSM addresses the topic of absolute value. As I looked through Discovering Algebra: An Investigative Approach, I saw the typical "distance from zero" definition followed by an investigation that included this rather unhelpful picture and caption:

(Clearly portrays Elvis? The middle guy looks like Matthew Perry joined a Vegas lion-taming act.)

From there, Discovering Algebra presents students with equations to solve, such as:

$$ | x - 2| + 7 = 12 $$

But do the CCSSM call for solving these kinds of equations? I went searching through the CCSSM for all mentions I could find of absolute value, and here's what I found.

Grade 6


CCSS.Math.Content.6.NS.C.7 Understand ordering and absolute value of rational numbers.
CCSS.Math.Content.6.NS.C.7a Interpret statements of inequality as statements about the relative position of two numbers on a number line diagram. For example, interpret –3 > –7 as a statement that –3 is located to the right of –7 on a number line oriented from left to right.
CCSS.Math.Content.6.NS.C.7b Write, interpret, and explain statements of order for rational numbers in real-world contexts. For example, write –3 oC > –7 oC to express the fact that –3oC is warmer than –7 oC.
CCSS.Math.Content.6.NS.C.7c Understand the absolute value of a rational number as its distance from 0 on the number line; interpret absolute value as magnitude for a positive or negative quantity in a real-world situation. For example, for an account balance of –30 dollars, write |–30| = 30 to describe the size of the debt in dollars.
CCSS.Math.Content.6.NS.C.7d Distinguish comparisons of absolute value from statements about order. For example, recognize that an account balance less than –30 dollars represents a debt greater than 30 dollars.
CCSS.Math.Content.6.NS.C.8 Solve real-world and mathematical problems by graphing points in all four quadrants of the coordinate plane. Include use of coordinates and absolute value to find distances between points with the same first coordinate or the same second coordinate.

and

CCSS.Math.Content.6.SP.B.5c Giving quantitative measures of center (median and/or mean) and variability (interquartile range and/or mean absolute deviation), as well as describing any overall pattern and any striking deviations from the overall pattern with reference to the context in which the data were gathered.

If all goes according to plan, there shouldn't be a need to define absolute value in 8th or 9th grade algebra, as it will already have been introduced in 6th grade. I know there are concerns about content being "developmentally inappropriate" for lower grade levels in the CCSSM, but without any personal data to the contrary, I imagine students could come to understand absolute value along with understanding positive and negative numbers. The last standard above, from the moment I first saw it, has been a point of fascination for me. How will 6th grade teachers help students learn topics like interquartile range and mean absolute deviation? You need absolute value for mean absolute deviation, but I don't think that will be the hangup for those who struggle with that standard.

So where else is absolute value mentioned?

Grade 7


CCSS.Math.Content.7.NS.A.1c Understand subtraction of rational numbers as adding the additive inverse, p – q = p + (–q). Show that the distance between two rational numbers on the number line is the absolute value of their difference, and apply this principle in real-world contexts.

and

CCSS.Math.Content.7.SP.B.3 Informally assess the degree of visual overlap of two numerical data distributions with similar variabilities, measuring the difference between the centers by expressing it as a multiple of a measure of variability. For example, the mean height of players on the basketball team is 10 cm greater than the mean height of players on the soccer team, about twice the variability (mean absolute deviation) on either team; on a dot plot, the separation between the two distributions of heights is noticeable.

Now we have absolute value as it relates to subtraction, and we get another mention of mean absolute deviation in the 7th grade statistics and probability standards. There's nothing yet about solving equations with absolute value or graphing absolute value functions.

Grade 8


Nothing. No mention of absolute value or mean absolute deviation.

High School


The CCSSM doesn't specify what specifically belongs in 9th grade versus other grades, but here's what I found across the whole of the HS CCSSM standards.

CCSS.Math.Content.HSN-VM.C.12 (+) Work with 2 × 2 matrices as a transformations of the plane, and interpret the absolute value of the determinant in terms of area.

CCSS.Math.Content.HSA-REI.D.11 Explain why the x-coordinates of the points where the graphs of the equations y = f(x) and y = g(x) intersect are the solutions of the equation f(x) = g(x); find the solutions approximately, e.g., using technology to graph the functions, make tables of values, or find successive approximations. Include cases where f(x) and/or g(x) are linear, polynomial, rational, absolute value, exponential, and logarithmic functions.

CCSS.Math.Content.HSF-IF.C.7b Graph square root, cube root, and piecewise-defined functions, including step functions and absolute value functions.

The first of the three standards above, I think we can agree, goes well beyond what we'd expect to find in a traditional Algebra 1 class. The other two standards address the graphing of various kinds of functions, and depending on the activity might belong in either a traditional Algebra 1 or Algebra 2 course, or more likely, both. But do you notice what's not there? Solving equations with absolute value functions. Sorry, \( | x - 2 | + 7 = 12 \), but it looks like you didn't get invited to the CCSSM party. Even if you interpret the second standard to include solving absolute value equations, it only asks for an approximation or to use technology.

Conundrum

The researcher in me wonders what Algebra 1 teachers will do when they get to a lesson on absolute value. Will some just teach it out of habit? Will some think it was excluded due to a CCSSM oversight? Will some modify the lesson to emphasize the graphing of absolute value, but not solving absolute value equations? How many will not even notice it went missing from the standards? Will anyone be willing to kill the little darling?

For years we've lamented math curricula in the United States that was "a mile wide and an inch deep." Given a fixed amount of time, going deeper means going narrower, and there is evidence that the CCSSM supports that (Porter, McMaken, Hwang, & Yang, 2011). For reasons I perceive to be mostly political, the Common Core State Standards don't go out of their way to specifically address content omitted compared to previous standards documents. In 1989, NCTM made a list of areas of emphasis and de-emphasis and many an argument in the math wars was waged using false dichotomies rooted in those lists. I'm sure those who wrote the CCSSM didn't want a repeat of those arguments, so now math teachers and those who support them are left to dig through the standards and find these omissions on their own.

(By the way, if you're looking for an interesting lesson for understanding and graphing absolute value, NCTM is offering one from a recent Mathematics Teacher for complimentary download: Angela Wade's "Teaching Absolute Value Meaningfully.")

References

Porter, A. C., McMaken, J., Hwang, J., & Yang, R. (2011). Common Core standards: The new U.S. intended curriculum. Educational Researcher, 40(3), 103–116. doi:10.3102/0013189X11405038