RYSK: Cobb, Zhao, & Visnovska's Learning From and Adapting the Theory of Realistic Mathematics Education (2008)

This is the 21st in a series describing "Research You Should Know" (RYSK).

It's Open Access Week (#OAweek) so I thought it would be fitting to use this "research you should know" post to highlight one of my favorite open access articles in mathematics education, Learning From and Adapting the Theory of Realistic Mathematics Education by Paul Cobb, Qing Zhao, and Jana Visnovska. Because the article is open access, I get to be less interested in summarizing it and more interested in giving you a reason to read it.

Realistic Mathematics Education (RME) is a theory for the design and development of mathematics curriculum. It is still deeply rooted in the Netherlands, where Hans Freudenthal greatly influenced mathematics instruction there with his belief that mathematics was a human activity, and that activity was characterized by mathematizing the real or readily imagined world. ("Realistic" comes from the Dutch phrase "zich realiseren," which in English means "to imagine.") This mathematization can be thought of in two ways, horizontal and vertical: "horizontal mathematization involves going from the world of life into the world of symbols, while vertical mathematization means moving within the world of symbols" (Freudenthal, 1991). Hans Freudenthal died in 1990 but his work continues, primarily at the Freudenthal Institute for Science and Mathematics Education at the University of Utrecht in the Netherlands.

There have been four primary avenues where RME has established itself in the United States. The first is with the middle school curriculum series Mathematics in Context, which grew from a partnership between mathematics education researchers at the University of Wisconsin (primarily Thomas Romberg) and researchers at the Freudenthal Institute. The second is the K-8-focused work of Mathematics in the City, which primarily brought together Cathy Fosnot from the City College of New York and Maarten Dolk of the Freudenthal Institute. The pair also wrote most of the Young Mathematicians at Work book series. The third place where RME is established in the U.S. is here at CU-Boulder, home of Freudenthal Institute US and its director, David Webb. David worked on the Mathematics in Context project at Wisconsin, and brought FI-US with him to CU-Boulder. The fourth place I recognize RME having a significant influence in the United States is in the work of Paul Cobb, particularly in his long research partnership with Koeno Gravemeijer, a researcher from the Freudenthal Institute. Cobb and Gravemeijer spent more than a decade working and publishing together, and that work did a lot to strengthen ties between RME as a design theory and theories in the learning sciences.

Like any idea or theory, RME has limitations. Over its 40+ years of existence it's proven to not be a static thing (van den Heuvel-Panhuizen, 2002), and this article by Cobb, Zhao, & Visnovska describes some of the important ways their work has both informed and been influenced by RME. They describe three adaptations: the first involves accounting for classroom activity and discourse in RME, the second acknowledges the mediating role of the teacher in making curriculum modifications and adaptations, and the third looks at how RME can focus on teacher learning, not just student learning. For details, I'll let you read the article for yourself at http://educationdidactique.revues.org/276. If you have any questions about the article or RME, leave a comment, find me on social media, or email me. We RME folks want to spread the word!

References

Freudenthal, H. (1991). Revisiting Mathematics Education: China Lectures. Dordrecht: Kluwer.

van den Heuvel-Panhuizen, M. (2002). Realistic Mathematics Education as work in progress. In F. L. Lin (Ed.), Common Sense in Mathematics Education: Proceedings of 2001 The Netherlands and Taiwan Conference on Mathematics Education (pp. 1–39). Taipei, Taiwan.

RME4: Webb's Opening Remarks

Opening Session - Friday, September 27, 2013

David Webb - Executive Director of Freudenthal Institute US and Associate Professor of Mathematics Education, University of Colorado Boulder

David Webb
David Webb welcomed us to the 4th International Realistic Mathematics Education Conference (#RME4) by addressing a shift in organizational structures. What used to be simply the Freudenthal Institute in the Netherlands is now the Freudenthal Institute for Science and Mathematics Education, and its American counterpart, Freudenthal Institute US, is now part of a larger CU-Boulder effort known as the Center for STEM Learning. These shifts reflect a desire to not just have cooperation between mathematics and science disciplines, but a perceived need to create innovative new STEM curricula along with the supporting frameworks, teacher education, and professional development to support it. Webb announced that earlier in the week that FISME and the Center for STEM Learning had formally agreed to collaborate, although we'll have to wait and see how this collaboration takes shape.

At its core, RME is a set of principles for curriculum design. It is sensible, then, to seek common ground in mathematics and the sciences for ideas upon which we can design curriculum. Some of that common ground is found in how we reason in math and science, and Webb offered these four activities:

  • Recognition of patterns
  • Making conjectures from observation
  • Reasoning from evidence
  • Generating new evidence

From these, we can think about how we consider the acts of modeling, problem solving, generalizing, and proving in both math and science. There are similarities and differences, and these things are meant as a starting point, not a definitive list. Perhaps the most fundamental RME principle is that of progressive formalization (see here for an example), so we must also think about how informal contexts can be used in both math and science, as well as the preformal models and representations that support more formal kinds of student thinking. Webb encouraged us to consider these RME traditions as we stretched ourselves beyond our usual disciplines, and with that the conference was underway.

NCTM Annual Meeting Fee Frustration (Updated 9-18)

I was recently informed by NCTM that my proposal to speak at the 2014 NCTM Annual Meeting was accepted. That's the good news. Unlike last year, when the conference was held in my backyard of Denver, I hesitated to accept NCTM's invitation to speak because of the costs involved. Registration fees, hotels, and transportation add up alarmingly quickly, especially for a graduate student getting by on a modest stipend and student loans.

Today I decided to accept the invitation and proceeded through NCTM's multi-step process. Step 1 was to accept, which was done with a quick login and a few clicks. Step 2 was to register for the conference. The registration fee for lead speakers is $281. Okay, but what are the fees for regular attendees? Here are the fees listed at http://www.nctm.org/researchconf/:

Fees at http://www.nctm.org/researchconf/, current as of 9/17/13.

Do you see what I see? If I were a regular NCTM member, the full, early-bird fee would be $345, which means the $281 speaker fee represents a $64 discount. That's a nice way to show your appreciation to speakers, isn't it? But what about student NCTM members? My full, early-bird fee is $172, which means the $281 speaker fee represents a $109 penalty.

Why is this? Does NCTM want to discourage students from presenting? I doubt it, but unless they get their fee structure sorted out that might be the result. I've emailed NCTM about this issue, and I hope they reply sensibly.

While I'm ranting, here's a selection of other things about this process that makes me mean:
  • Silly me did Step 1 before Step 2, which mean I accepted before checking out the speaker fee. Even worse, NCTM warns you that accepting then cancelling puts you in the NCTM doghouse and decreases the chances that any future proposals get accepted.
  • Too many policies at http://www.nctm.org/speak/neworleans/ disappoint me, such as:
    • Remember that recording of Steven Leinwand's talk I posted from the last Annual Meeting? That apparently is (or will be) against NCTM's wishes, as they state: "Written permission to tape or record presentations must be obtained directly from the speaker involved at least thirty days before the NCTM Annual Meeting & Exposition. The request must contain a statement indicating the intended use of such a recording or videotape. The person making the request should also inform the NCTM Headquarters Office in writing at least two weeks prior to the NCTM Annual Meeting & Exposition." I had Leinwand's permission to post the recording, but didn't get that permission from him in advance.
    • If you aren't a lead speaker, but a co-speaker, your registration rate is $344. Yes, a $1 discount compared to the regular, early-bird registration rate. That's like leaving your waitstaff a nickel tip. I'm assuming this higher fee applies to students, too.
    • Speakers must submit a written request to use any art related to the Annual Meeting. I can't imagine there's any real risk to just letting registered speakers download that from the password-protected speaker's website.
    • NCTM's idea of "going green" is to pick up your program book when you register so they don't have to mail it to you. This wouldn't have struck me as strange 10 years ago, but it sure does now. Why not try this, NCTM: Tell everyone that program books will be available electronically, and those wishing a paper copy can pay an extra $5 with their registration. That way you'll have an estimate of how many copies to print, and be "going green" 2014-style.

UPDATE! (Wednesday, September 18)

I received a reply this morning from Michael Barbagallo, Senior Manager of Member Services at NCTM. He said I can pay the student rate and not the speaker rate, but their system does not currently give me a way to register as a student until registration opens to everyone in November. For now I should confirm I will present (which I've done) and book my hotel room (uhh...can I just bring a tent and a sleeping bag to New Orleans?), then NCTM will sort things out in November when I register for the conference. It sounds like there's no automated way to do this and according to Mr. Barbagallo, "we have few students who speak." To that, I say to grad students: I know the culture of academia and research tells us that presenting at research conferences deserves higher priority than presenting at teacher conferences. Cultures can be changed and good things often come when they are challenged.

Teaching Statistics: Textbook Considerations

I have the pleasure of teaching an undergraduate basic statistics class this fall for the third consecutive year. It's not a class I had any specific preparation to teach, but I've tried to make up for that by becoming familiar with some of the statistics education literature, bolstering my content knowledge (although I doubt it will ever be as wide or deep as I'd like), getting access to good resources, and being mindful of the needs of my students.

First, it would help to know a little bit about the course. Most strikingly, the class only meets once a week on a Thursday from 4:30 to 7. If you're used to teaching 180-day school years, you really have to wrap your head quickly around the idea that you're only going to see these students 15 times before finals. Also, despite the class being taught in the School of Education, it's not required of any education students. Instead, the class consists mostly of students from two majors: Sociology and Speech, Language, and Hearing Sciences. Honestly, most of them admit to avoiding math classes, but they usually need the stats class to apply for graduate school. As for the content of the course, here is how it is described in the university catalog:

Introduces descriptive statistics including graphic presentation of data, measures of central tendency and variability, correlation and prediction, and basic inferential statistics, including the t-test.

And that's it. As someone who works almost daily with the Common Core State Standards, building a course around such a sparse description would be quite a challenge, especially for a first-time instructor. When I talked to Derek Briggs about teaching the course, he advised that I use his preferred text, Statistics by Freedman, Pisani, and Purves. I'd recently used Agresti and Finlay's Statistical Methods for the Social Sciences for my qualitative methods courses, and while that book suited me pretty well, I was open to something different so I ordered the Freedman text for my class.

In hindsight, the Freedman text was fine, and the Agresti text would have been fine, too. Both were decently well-written and had plenty of problems to assign, but that's the thing — I was looking for a text that offered considerably more than explanations followed by problem sets. I really wanted something that supported students working together in groups during class, making sense of the material as we went along.

One book that had gotten my attention was Workshop Statistics: Discovery with Data by Rossman and Chance. I recognized Beth Chance's name immediately from some of the stats education literature I'd read, and felt good that this text would offer what I was looking for. I used the text last year and was not disappointed, and will be using it again this year. Below is a summary of some of the reasons I like Workshop Statistics.

Context Continuity

In the front matter of the book, Workshop Statistics contains a list of activities by application — in other words, they've categorized all the problems by context and indexed exactly where those contexts get used. The list of related problems appears again with each problem in the text (inset in picture above), so it's easy for me or my students to refer back or forward to where that context appears. I believe in teaching mathematics rooted in context when possible, so I found this an especially helpful way of finding problems that might be relevant or interesting to the students in my class.

Preliminaries

Every topic (lesson) in the text opens with some preliminary questions. Some involve data collection, which is great, but at the very least it gives students an opportunity to consider a question and how we might answer it. If Dan Meyer has made anything clear, it's that we shouldn't teach math as finding answers to questions that nobody has bothered to ask.

In Brief

The end-of-topic summary certainly isn't unique to this text, but the "You should be able to" statements are very handy for writing objectives for standards-based grading. (I hope to write about my SBG approach in a future post.)

Online Supports and Simulations

Besides both online instructor and student resources, the text uses a number of custom applets that often really help illustrate some of the concepts in the course. Some are Java, but a number have been converted to JavaScript for use on more platforms. I've avoided having students use software beyond a spreadsheet, and some of these applets have saved us from having to purchase SPSS (expensive!) or trying to use R (steep learning curve!).

Activities

The in-class activities use some interesting contexts and support groups working together. If anything they can be a bit over-scaffolded, but that relieves me from having to lecture much and I can spend most of my time going group-to-group in the classroom and dealing with questions more intimately.

Overall

There are a number of smaller things that I'm fine with, although they aren't deal-makers or deal-breakers. The pacing of the text is good — if we cover about two topics a week, we finish the text and pretty much everything one would expect in a basic statistics course. The order of the topics is sensible, too. Typically, it makes sense to put descriptive statistics before inferential statistics, and to work from one-variable stats to two-variable stats. This book is no different. Some texts put linear regression earlier, and where probability should land in a book seems to be negotiable. The placement of those topics in this book is fine for this course and the progression from topic to topic was very manageable.

Other than my first day activity, I haven't written much about teaching stats, but look for me to change that this semester.

Starting the Standards Era: NCTM and the 1980s (Part 6 of 6, Focusing the Council on Standards)

(See Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, and Part 5 of this six-part series.)

The successful release of the 1989 NCTM Standards paved the way for the release of the next two NCTM standards documents, the Professional Standards for Teaching Mathematics (1991) and the Assessment Standards for School Mathematics (1995). While neither received all the attention of the 1989 Standards, a change in administration in the federal government and changing attitudes at private foundations meant money for later Standards-based projects was more easily obtainable.

In order to provide teachers and district-level mathematics specialists a clearer vision of what Standards-guided lessons would look like, the NCTM launched a project called the Addenda Series, with a committee chaired by Bonnie Litwiller of the University of Northern Iowa1. Although initially intended to produce just a few books a year for one or two years, the project eventually produced 22 books in five years, covering all grade levels K-12. Each book in the Addenda Series provided a set of lesson plans that a teacher could use directly in his or her classroom, offering some of the specificity lacking in the original Standards. The Addenda Series also supported NCTM financially, as it became their most profitable set of publications (S. Frye, personal communication, April 19, 2013).

In order to focus all the NCTM publications on the Standards, a deliberate effort was made by the editors of NCTM's journals to acquire and publish articles that cited the Standards (Lindquist, 2003, p. 837). Authors of research articles that did not refer to the Standards were asked as part of the peer review process to refocus their writing to include the Standards. With this de-facto policy in place, soon nearly every article listed the Standards as a reference. Somewhat ironically, the Standards themselves contain a reference list of only 27 sources (NCTM, 1989, pp. 257-258).

Conclusion

The creation and publication of the NCTM Standards is generally recognized as the event that launched our current era of standards-based reform. Given the rapidity with which educational reforms come and go, such a lasting impact from a document published almost 25 years ago deserves to be well-understood by education policymakers as well as teachers and other education stakeholders. The most significant positive, negative, and fortunate aspects of NCTM's Standards process can be summarized as:

Positive:

  • Leadership desired an organization-level policy influence.
  • Working groups possessed expertise and represented diverse stakeholders.
  • Goals were set conservatively in an effort to broaden public acceptance.
  • Drafts of the Standards were sent to a very wide audience for review and commentary.
  • Standards were promoted through a massive public relations campaign.

Negative:

  • Despite seeking consensus, reconciliation with the most vocal critics in the mathematics community has yet to happen.
  • The working groups lacked writing talent.

Fortunate:

  • A well-timed "crisis" came in the form of A Nation at Risk.
  • NCTM membership rebounded in the mid-80s before the Standards project had an opportunity to put the organization in greater financial jeopardy.
  • Attitudes about the federal government's role in education, as well as national efforts like the Standards, became more favorable after the end of the Reagan Administration.

It's evident that NCTM's leadership in standards-based educational reform didn't come without a sizeable bit of good fortune. The shifting of any number of events by a year or two might have jeopardized the entire process, or relegated the Standards to be that "book on the shelf" to which few paid much attention.

When compared to the Common Core State Standards, a few significant differences stand out to me. First, the NCTM Standards were created largely for the purposes of comparing and judging curriculum, whereas the CCSSM were created as student learning targets and as part of a larger accountability structure. The NCTM Standards were not grade-level specific like the CCSSM, nor were they ever "adopted" wholesale by states or districts. Instead, the NCTM Standards became a foundation for states and districts to write their own standards, and the CCSSM represents the effort to de-duplicate the efforts of states by having a single, agreed-upon set of standards. Although not without their detractors, standards efforts on this scale do have the potential to drive positive change and anchor collaboration between educators across states and districts. Time will tell if any lasting effects of the CCSSM measure up to those of the NCTM Standards, and how.

References

Lindquist, M. M. (2003). My perspective on the NCTM Standards. In G. M. A. Stanic & J. Kilpatrick (Eds.), A History of School Mathematics (pp. 819-842). Reston, VA: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.

National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. (1989). Curriculum and evaluation standards for school mathematics. Reston, VA: Author.

National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. (1991). Professional standards for teaching mathematics (p. 196). Reston, VA: Author.

National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. (1995). Assessment standards for school mathematics (p. 102). Reston, VA: Author.


  1. Bonnie Litwiller was my academic advisor and twice my methods professor while I was an undergraduate mathematics major at UNI.