Feeling around in the dark to understand the elephant of local control

The view from my new office.
Educationally, Colorado is a "local control" state, and I know this because I've heard many people say it. I once read something that said "there are only six local control states," and I assumed Colorado was one of them. (I also assume many more than six states would claim to belong on the list.) The document did not list the states or describe the difference between local and not-quite-local. But by all other accounts I've seen and heard, Colorado is a local control state.

Today was my first day in my new job at the Colorado Department of Education, and at almost every turn I was reminded of Colorado's status as a local control state. Before I go further, let me be clear: I see many positives in local control and generally favor it. I appreciate that historically and politically we've entrusted our schools to the communities they serve, and I cherish my rural school experiences where the tight bonds between the school and the community generate a special sense of pride and responsibility.

Local control is not to be confused with insular, however. I've never known a school district where teachers and district officials didn't seek resources and guidance from outside their boundaries. In my new job, I'm now one of those outsiders who can offer some of those resources and guidance. But as an employee of the state, I have to be rather careful about the resources and guidance I give, lest anyone be confused about whether control lies with the state or with the school district.

It's a bit awkward, as you might expect. And it's becoming apparent to me how local control influences the things a CDE employee decides they can and cannot say is, well, a little arbitrary. Maybe arbitrary isn't the right description, but rather there's some socio-normative set of unwritten rules guiding all this that aren't 100% logical. For example, we believe local districts have the power to make curriculum decisions, not the state. But what does that mean? For me, I know without a doubt this means I have no power as a state employee to require that a district, school, or teacher use a particular set of textbooks. Okay, that's clear to me, but can I recommend a textbook, while plainly stating that textbook choices are not the state's decision? Again, this is something we expressly avoid at CDE because we don't want to give districts the impression that they're not in control of their curriculum. Let's make this even fuzzier: If someone asks me what textbooks I've personally used and why I chose to use them, can I answer? I certainly hope so, as I'd feel silly not answering the question. But with my answer, I have to be cautious that what I say is not construed as some kind of state endorsement of a particular textbook. Why? Local control, that's why.

Yet, there are numerous areas where we, the citizens of Colorado and our elected representatives, have decided the state should have control. The state dictates sets of academic standards, which are accompanied by all sorts of supporting documents. The state also requires the administration of assessments that measure student performance towards those standards, and by law the results of those assessments are used to hold local educators accountable. Whether I approve or disapprove of these things is irrelevant in the current discussion, because I only name them to illustrate how the state has control over things that might not be textbooks or curriculum, yet have undeniable influence over local educators' choice of curriculum and related materials. We still claim to have a system of local control, but it shows that local vs. state control of schools is beyond a simple binary classification.

I'm reminded of a pair of sessions I attended at the Realistic Mathematics Education Conference in 2013. The first was from several people from CDE, who presented a series of standards implementation materials they developed in cooperation with local educators. The second presentation came from national curriculum developers from The Netherlands, who showed their new integrated STEM curriculum materials. Both groups sincerely wanted high-quality educational experiences for students, but CDE illustrated the more traditionally American approach of building out documents and tools to support local decision-makers, instead of developing student-facing curriculum materials, as seen in The Netherlands. Dutch schools are not required to use materials developed by their national curriculum office, so you can say there's still an element of local control there. But at a national/state level they do experience a broader set of options for what they produce for schools, and these options are supported by a different political and cultural climate than we generally find in the United States.

Without belaboring the issue much further, I hope by now you get a little sense of the tension I'm feeling in my new position. I'm grappling with my new role and how my actions and words will be shaped by issues of local control, this elephant in the dark room that I felt my hands on all day. A lot of "what-ifs" came to mind, and some of them yield unsatisfactory possibilities. I'm frustrated by thoughts of continually almost doing curriculum work, and I don't think anyone wants to produce supplementary documentation just for the sake of producing it. With what I currently see offered for mathematics from CDE, there's a lot of value in the details, but it's a pretty overwhelming mass of stuff at first (and second) glance. That's not going to change overnight, but for me, after Day 1 on the job, I think the best thing I can do is think openly about this and to explore the boundaries of what is reasonable and possible. Ultimately, I serve the teachers and educators of Colorado, and for now, I can be honest about the thought I put into these things, even if I don't anticipate easy answers anytime soon.

A day in the life of a Ph.D. candidate

7:30 Wake up, roll over, and begin my day by checking email, Twitter, Google+, and RSS feeds.

8:15 Actually get out of bed and get ready for the day.

9:00 Sit at desk and start working. Listen to Science Friday podcasts on 2x speed in the background. My first task is to apply for a travel grant I'm hoping will help get me to NCTM. Task #2 is to follow up on some other travel funding I applied for.

9:45 Snack.

10:00 Prepare expense report and receipt for student infographics I printed for Inquiry Hub. It amazes me how much technology I use even for a simple task like this: Taking a picture of the receipt with the Microsoft Office Lens app on my phone, uploading it as a PDF to OneDrive, using Adobe Reader to fill out and digitally sign the expense report (with a password saved in LastPass), and using BitTorrent Sync to sync OneDrive to my Linux desktop, where I save files and do most my work. Science Friday has given way to Leo Laporte's The Tech Guy podcasts.
A glimpse of what I have in Pocket Casts

10:30 Work on a new "This Week in Math Ed" post. I was smarter this week and started writing earlier in the week as I saw some of the posts.

11:30 Lunch.

11:45 I'm back to work and reviewing recent research. I pause the podcasts to help me keep focus as I'd like to get through a few articles in a relatively short amount of time.

1:00 Break. So much for getting through multiple articles quickly. I started one and decided it wasn't a good fit for the post, then dug too deep into the next and ended up summarizing it on the MathEd.net Wiki.

1:20 Back to the research and writing.

3:15 I finally wrap up the blog post and send it out on Twitter and Google+. Time for another break.

3:45 Email wrangling. In 30 minutes I manage to delete, archive, reply to, or otherwise act upon about 40 emails, which only leaves me with about 100 unread. Try as I might, I've never quite developed habits that keep me at or very near inbox zero.

4:15 Dig into some administrative stuff to follow-up on some of my teaching duties from last semester. I told myself I'd get it done the first week back, and the last minutes of that first week are here.

5:00 I keep working, but turn on Tech News Today to catch some of the day's tech news.

6:00 Dinner time. Watch the Daily Tech News Show to get even more tech news. I'm still not done with the 4:15 task, but I set it aside for awhile.

Wisconsin won 1 match tonight. Ask Northwestern fans -- it could be worse.
7:00 On the bike. I aim for an hour of activity every day, and many days that means I'm on my exercise bike for an hour in the evening. Today I planned it this way so I could watch the Iowa-Wisconsin wrestling dual meet while I pedaled. Today's ride went about 20 miles, which puts me at 289 miles so far this year.

8:00 I finish watching the wrestling meet and send some email. I'm running out of steam at this point so everything I do seems to take longer.

9:45 Wrap up the 4:15 task, which thankfully had little left to do.

Bill Penuel-approved reading.
10:00 I concede that there's not just much productivity left in me today. Like too many days, I finish and think, "Where could I have found time to work on my dissertation?" In this case, I really thought I'd get through my mid-day blogging faster than I did. Writing now wouldn't go well, so I'll settle for some reading. Tony Bryk's book was delivered yesterday, and if I'm lucky I'll stay awake long enough to get through 10 pages.

This Week in Math Ed: January 15, 2016

Math Ed Said

January 8: NCTM, Regan Galvan, Math for America, and Bridget Dunbar tweeted this Chalkbeat story about New York City having specialized math teachers as a strategy to improving algebra readiness. I think this approach has some real promise (there's probably research on the effectiveness of elementary math specialists, but I don't know it), and I wish them luck figuring out what I imagine will be some tricky staffing and logistical issues to make it happen. Interestingly, Redwood Falls, Minnesota, plans on doing the exact opposite.

January 9: Suzanne Alejandre, Tina Cardone, Ashli Black, Diana Suddreth, Anna Blinstein, Bowen Kerins, and OCTM were all talking about the Park City Math Institute's Teacher Leadership Program. Applications are due TODAY, and good luck to all those who applied!

Jo Boaler presenting at the 2015 NCTM Annual Meeting
January 10: Jo Boaler's Hechinger Report article from last May, "Memorizers Are the Lowest Achievers and Other Common Core Math Surprises", was made the rounds Sunday thanks to Ilana Horn, Robert Talbert, Sara VanDerWerf, Andrew Gael, Dan Anderson, and George Woodbury. Here, Jo encourages us to be more patient with the learning of mathematics rather than marching through memorization and fact drills on a race to calculus.

January 11: The blogosphere is abuzz with Week 1 of the 2016 MTBoS blogging initiative. Tina Cardone, Gregory Taylor, Jon Orr, Kristina Danahy, Kyle Pearce, and Danielle Reycer were all busy on Monday sharing, resharing, and/or encouraging people to share blog posts.

January 12: Teaching Children Math, NCTM, Richelle Marynowski, Fawn Nguyen, and UCTM shared "Practıcal Problems: Using Literature to Teach Statistics", an article in the NCTM elementary journal, Teaching Children Mathematics. This was one of the most-shared links all week long, and for good reason: the activities in NCTM's teacher journals tend to be very well written and edited, and this article was both free and was the focus of the first #TCMchat on Twitter. The authors of the TCM article, Mairéad Hourigan and Aisling Leavy of Mary Immaculate College, Ireland, have several related publications here and here in the journal Teaching Statistics.

January 13: Egan Chernoff, Andrew Shauver, Josh Fisher, and Katherine Bryant shared Ben Orlin's "Simplify," the latest in his series of Math With Bad Drawings. Having done a few (tens of thousands) "simplify" problems myself, I've come to see "simplify" to mean, "re-write this according to the convention your teacher/student/reader would expect or appreciate." Ben takes this further and uses the idea of "paraphrasing" to emphasize that many of our symbol manipulations are transformations on objects whose value remains the same.

January 14: The most-shared link of the day pointed to a Storify of Tuesday's #TCMchat, but coming in 2nd was a story at Quartz titled "The Stanford professor who pioneered praising kids for effort says we’ve totally missed the point". "Mindset" has been perhaps the biggest education buzzword of the past couple of years ("practice" or "practices," as nouns, are another) and this article and the comments from Carol Dweck remind me of two things: (1) Uri Treisman's 2014 NCTM Research Conference plenary in which he said that it's a "parlor trick" to shift away from a fixed mindset for a short time, but lasting change is something we have a lot still to learn about, and (2) this SMBC comic from last week. Thanks to Elizabeth Statmore, John Golden, Mr. Harris, Denise Gaskins, Anna Hester, Avery Pickford, and Ron King for sharing.

Research Notes

I spent time this week curating a list of journals to follow and organize their RSS feeds. As much as I'd like to mention or describe all the research that crosses my path, there's just no way I can keep up with all of it. I'll do my best to choose 2-3 new articles this week, give them a quick looking-over (studying and understanding an article in-depth can take hours), and summarizing a bit here.

Educational Studies in Mathematics has already published new issues for January and February.

Csaba Csíkos at the University of Szeged, Hungary, published "Strategies and Performance in Elementary Students' Three-Digit Mental Addition" in ESM. Working with 78 4th grade students, Csíkos wanted to explore students' less-routine approaches to mental calculation in terms of strategy, speed, and accuracy. Bottom line? He didn't see as much of a relationship between strategy, response time, and success rate on tasks as you might think, although that might have been due to limitations in the study. I won't go on about it here, but I've summarized more of this article on the MathEd.net Wiki.

In Teaching and Teacher Education, Beth Clark-Gareca at Teachers College wrote, "Classroom Assessment and English Language Learners: Teachers' Accommodations Implementation on Routine Math and Science Tests." Working with 213 Pennsylvania elementary teachers, her findings are humbling: 65% of teachers said they weren't sure about the WIDA scores or proficiency levels of their ESL students. Ninety-six percent of teachers surveyed claimed fluency only in English. Overall, however, teachers did make the most test accommodations for students at the beginning and intermediate levels of English language proficiency. Additional time on assessments was a common accommodation, with one-on-one help, a translator, and dictionaries were less commonly used. Tests that included the native language of the test-taker were rarely used. ELL students who were not also identified as needing special education services often got fewer language accommodations as students receiving special education services.

The Journal of Mathematical Behavior is in the process of publishing their March issue, with these articles so far:
The above research represents maybe half of the tabs I opened in the past week as I found new articles, but I'm stopping here for this week! Also, math ed folks that do great work in the journal world but have horrible Google search results make me sad. (If RateMyProfessor or some such site ranks higher than your faculty page, you have a problem.)

Math Ed in the News

Did I miss anything? If so, feel free to mention it in the comments!

New year, new job

Exciting news! Starting January 19, I will be the new mathematics content specialist for the Colorado Department of Education (CDE). Whenever people would ask me about what kinds of jobs I might be interested in doing after grad school, I always mentioned this one or ones like it. It's a mixture of curriculum work, policy, assessment, teacher education, and communication — all the things I've focused on during my time as a graduate student. Of course, there's only one such job in the state of Colorado, so it was my good fortune that the job came open (relatively) near the end of my time as a graduate student. To help ease the transition, CDE is generously allowing me to start the job part-time while I complete work here at CU-Boulder. Thankfully, my new colleagues at CDE are well-aware of the challenges of finishing a Ph.D. and are willing to be flexible so that I can complete my degree. As educators I think we're all on the same page when it comes to helping students (even a supposedly grown-up one, like me) see their program through to the end.

What will the new job mean for this blog and my other online activities? If I have anything to say about it, the blogging, tweeting, Google-plussing, etc. will only get better. (I may even have to venture more frequently into Facebook for my professional use, as well as LinkedIn.) As a researcher (even the graduate student kind), there's a large expectation to share with others in the research community. But in this role as math specialist, I plan to make sharing of research, policy perspectives, projects and collaborations, etc. part of my full-time work, with the goal of bringing it to math educators across Colorado and beyond. I look forward to sharing more of the great work I see teachers doing, along with the hard-earned lessons we collectively learn along the way. I also look forward to bringing more transparency to a state agency. Yes, there are a few things I can't say on the job (for example, in Colorado the state doesn't tell school districts what curriculum to use), but to the extent I can keep sharing, I will!

This Week in Math Ed: January 8, 2016

Last year was not a productive blogging year for me, so I hope this post is the first of many in which I recap the goings-on in the mathematics education community. I see two benefits of doing this: (1) I can help others by finding, curating, and annotating the enormous amount of everything that might be of interest to us in the mathematics education community, and (2) it will encourage me to keep up and engage with more of the best stuff being shared and published. I've thought of doing this in newsletter or podcast form, but I'll start with blog posts until I get some traction.

Math Ed Said

I may follow fewer than 200 people with my @MathEdnet Twitter account, but over the years, I've amassed a MathEd Twitter list of nearly 1300 people. I curate the list pretty carefully by only adding people who appear to primarily tweet about math education and related issues. (Know someone who should be on the list but isn't? Tell me!) Here are the most-shared links from people on the list over the past week:

January 1: Ryan Ruff, Matthew Oldridge, Gary Davis, Chi Klein, and Bridget Dunbar were all sharing Jo Boaler's latest article in The Atlantic, The Math-Class Paradox. In the article, Boaler says we should work harder to focus on the learning that can happen in math classes, and less on student performance. Like other pieces Boaler has written over the past few years, this encourages us to steer clear of excessive assessment, timed tests, and pedagogy that gives students the impression math is all about facts and rules.

January 2: Federico Chialvo, Markus Sagebiel, John Golden, Katrina Hall, and Bridget Dunbar all shared Dan Meyer's blog post, "I'm gonna use my formula sheets and that's the only way I'm gonna do stuff". Dan highlights a recent New York Times piece in which a deposition by an expert witness becomes very uncomfortable when the witness isn't able to do what should be an easy mathematics problem.

January 3: Cathy Yenca, Lisa Bejarano, Jennifer Fairbanks, Mary Bourassa, Megan Schmidt, and Tina Cardone shared the ExploreMTBoS kick-off of their 2016 blogging initiative. (For more on the MTBoS and math educators on Twitter, see the Math Ed Wiki.) The post includes some simple to-dos for both new and experienced bloggers to help everyone start the new year right.

January 4: Danielle Reycer, Tina Cardone, Bridget Dunbar, Graham Fletcher, James Cleveland, Fawn Nguyen, George Woodbury, Michael Pershan, and Sadie Estrella all shared Kate Nowak's plea to "Please be more boring" described in Kate's post, In Defense of Unsexy. Kate says that while finding novel tasks that are high in cognitive demand has become increasingly easy, we're lacking high-quality but lower-demand tasks that address fundamental concepts. Basic stuff. The post is worth reading for her Mario Batali vs. Rachel Ray analogy.

Tracy Zager presenting at the 2015 NCTM Annual Meeting
January 5: Michelle, Ruth Parker, Josh Fisher, Denise Gaskins, Larry Sizemore, Shauna Hedgepeth, Brian Anderson, Kate Nowak, David Coffey, Dan Meyer, Simon Gregg, Brian Bushart, Tim Hudson, and Christopher Danielson all shared Tracy Johnston Zager's excellent post, My Criteria for Fact-Based Apps. In her post, Tracy addresses a problem I've focused on for some time now in my dissertation work: While teachers and others have little trouble telling you what curriculum materials they like or dislike, it seems more difficult for people to clearly articulate the criteria they use for determining if something is good. Tracy does exactly this in her post, describing three criteria she uses when looking at fact-based math apps. This post gets my early vote for blog post of the year, and I hope others will follow Tracy by trying to articulate their criteria for choosing or recommending curricular materials.

January 6 and 7: Brett Gilland, Eric Milou, Keith Devlin, Kevin Moore, John Golden, Rachel Lambert, John Pelesko, Dylan Kane, Steve Phelps, Tracy Zager, and I made this comic from Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal the most linked-to post for two days running in my MathEd list. We laugh to keep from crying, right?

If you're looking for something else to read that was popular in the past week, try Matt Townsley's list of Top 10 Standards-Based Grading Articles. I won't say SBG is a panacea for all our educational ills, but I've tried various formations of it myself and encourage teachers to thoughtfully experiment with their grading and feedback systems in ways that put more attention on student performance on tasks and less on students' ego.

Research Notes

The Journal for Research in Mathematics Education (JRME) was first to cross my path in the new year with a new issue.

Richard Kitchen and Sarabeth Berk from the University of Denver wrote a research commentary about the challenge of using computer-assisted instruction to help students — particularly low-income students and students of color — meet the learning goals described in the Common Core state standards. The authors are concerned that schools and teachers will rely too heavily on technology for their mathematics instruction, despite shaky and inconclusive research regarding computer-aided instruction. I highly recommend reading their commentary, which is currently free for all to read on NCTM's site.

Charles Hohensee at the University of Delaware wrote a brief report called Teachers' Awareness of the Relationship Between Prior Knowledge and New Learning. At its most basic level, constructivism tells us that students' prior knowledge shapes their new learning. Honensee used a series of interviews with eight teachers to see if teachers noticed relationships between prior knowledge and new learning. Teachers were pretty good at identifying when students did or did not use their prior knowledge to learn something new, but it was less clear that teachers were aware of backward transfer, or how the new learning was influencing prior knowledge. What's backwards transfer? Here's an example from algebra: Students learn how to combine like terms and often do so with little difficulty. But then some short time later, students are introduced to solving equations and suddenly some struggle with basic "simplify" exercises because now they are trying to "do the same thing to both sides," even if there are no "sides" in the expression they're simplifying. Whereas solving equations should give students more practice and understanding of combining like terms, for some students this "backwards transfer" is unproductive and leads to errors. Hohensee has several examples: graphing speed-time graphs confuses students about distance-time; learning about exponential function growth confuses students about linear functions; multiplying and dividing integers confuses students about adding and subtracting; scientific notation confuses students about metric conversions; and complex fractions confuse students about unit rate. The more we learn about these problematic areas of backwards transfer, the better we can help prepare teachers to deal with them when they happen.

Lyn English at the Queensland University of Technology and Jane Watson at the University of Tasmania wrote Development of Probabilistic Understanding in Fourth Grade. Working with 91 Grade 4 students over 3 years, the authors designed a number of activities to help students better understand the relative frequency of possible outcomes.

Martin Simon, Nicora Placa, and Arnon Avitzur of NYU described a 2-year teaching experiment in their article, Participatory and Anticipatory Stages of Mathematical Concept Learning: Further Empirical and Theoretical Development. This article adds to what Tzur and Simon (2004) theorized about participatory and anticipatory stages of concept development, which attempts to help us understand why students can "get" something one day when they're engaged in an activity, but yet "forget" something the next day when they're asked to refer to what they learned. The article is mostly theory-focused, but it comes with hopes that by better understanding what is normally just chalked up to "forgetting" we'll be able to apply this knowledge in classrooms.

The open access journal Numeracy also published new articles in the new year, including:
Remember, Numeracy is open access so you can read any of these articles for yourself. Jumping into research can be rough if you're not used to it, but just do what we graduate students do: muddle your way through the best you can and then talk it out with others.

Whew! All this and I didn't get to other happenings, such as the MAA Joint Meetings in Seattle, the new year in the Global Math Department, or recent posts in the Google+ Math Education community. If you have suggestions, let me know!