NCTM Denver 2013: Business Meeting

Annual Meeting - Friday, April 19, 12:30 pm

I had no idea what to expect at the NCTM Business Meeting. It was scheduled to be in one of the larger rooms, so I was surprised to see only a dozen or so people there, huddled up and down the sides of the center aisle. Kichoon Yang, NCTM's soon-to-retire executive director, was about the only one standing. I walked in, then out, then back in the room again, and had to make sure the meeting was open to the public before sitting down.

The meeting was quick. There was some review of prior business and some quick votes on some proposed motions. The item of most interest to me was discussion of possibly moving the NCTM Annual Meeting to the summer. NCTM sent out a survey a few months ago to gauge interest in the move, as attendance at the Annual Meeting has declined as more states require testing in April. According to Yang, NCTM has many contractual agreements for the Annual Meeting stretching out five years or more, making rescheduling the Annual Meeting a possible, but non-trivial matter.

The person seated in front of me asked if the new Common Core-based consortia tests, PARCC and Smarter Balanced, would also have conflicting test dates in April. Yang said that would be a good thing to investigate. Shortly after I talked to the person who asked the question and realized it was Shirley Frye, Past President of NCTM in 1989, the year the first Standards were released. I think she was impressed that I knew that, and I explained to her my connections to Bonnie Litwiller (author of the Addenda project) and Ed Rathmell (co-author of the elementary standards, and someone I was happy to spend time with at the conference) at Northern Iowa. She was proud of how successful some of that work had been, particularly in the Addenda's ability to generate revenue for NCTM that was needed after taking a financial risk to produce the Standards. We didn't talk long, but as someone with an interest in the history of math education I think meeting Shirley Frye was among the true highlights of my week.

NCTM Denver 2013: Thrasher and Perry's Supporting Beginning Teachers through Online Social Communities

Annual Meeting - Friday, April 19, 11:00 am

Emily Thrasher - North Carolina State University
Ayanna Perry - North Carolina State University

At NC State University there is a program called the Noyce Mathematics Education Teaching Scholars, funded by the National Science Foundation. Along with providing preservice preparation, this program experimented with using online tools to support their graduates (called "Scholars" below) in their first years of teaching.

Thrasher and Perry

Thrasher and Perry cited the poor retention statistics for teachers, and hoped that this program would keep more of their Scholars in the classroom. Their approaches for continued contact and collaboration were organized into synchronous and asynchronous modes of communication.

Synchronous communication was mostly facilitated through real-time chat and Skype. Sometimes Skype included an expert panel or guest speakers. The group found that by being online everyone could participate, and Scholars liked keeping in touch with their former classmates. The synchronous meetings also provided time to discuss research-based practices and how the Scholars might use them in their classrooms. Unfortunately, scheduling synchronous communication was a persistent problem. Scholars didn't feel comfortable prioritizing a "virtual" meeting on their calendar and requested more face-to-face meetings. These face-to-face meetings were difficult because Scholars had taken jobs in various places across the country, but an effort was made to meet for on-campus professional development or to meetup at professional conferences several times throughout the year.

The group primarily used five tools to collaborate asynchronously: a wiki, a website, Dropbox, Facebook, and Google+. The initial plan was to use the wiki heavily, but Scholars were slow to adapt to the technology and needed facilitators to model how the tool could be used to share. Also, the presenters felt it was important to make the wiki private, as there were things the Scholars probably didn't want to be made public. The website served more as an archive of newsletters and activities, and did not facilitate much collaboration itself. Participation in Dropbox was perhaps the most successful, as Scholars found it very easy to create subfolders and submit lesson ideas and resources. The project didn't see much use for Facebook at first, judging it to be too informal, but it emerged as a place where Scholars and their former professors could keep in touch. Lastly, Google+ emerged as useful when several of the Scholars started using it to distribute and discuss self-made YouTube videos and links to lessons, as well as using Google's instant messaging features.

To judge the effectiveness of these efforts, the researchers observed classrooms and asked Scholars to reflect and discuss the data that was collected. While valuable, observations were limited by time and budget, and the presenters suggested that reviewing videos of lessons might have been a better strategy.

Of the 24 scholars in the program, two never taught and 19 of the remaining 22 are still teaching beyond their first year, so retention looks good thus far. Interestingly, some of the Scholars have taken considerable interest in discussing the research shared online, and that's caused some of them to consider leaving teaching for graduate school. While seeking more education is certainly not bad, it wasn't part of the plan to increase retention.

NCTM Denver 2013: Leinwand's Essential Mindsets for Tilling the Soil for the Common Core State Standards

Annual Meeting - Friday, April 19, 9:30 am

Steve Leinwand - American Institutes for Research, Washington, D.C.

There is perhaps nobody better at shouting math education's rallying cry than Steve Leinwand. Knowing that my notetaking could not keep up, I recorded Steve's talk for later review. Graciously, Steve has granted me permission to post it here. (Which saves me a ton of typing!) You can find slides for Leinwand's "Tilling the Soil" talk on his website.


Check this out on Chirbit

Dan Meyer covered the tweeting duties during the talk:























My takeaway? Math teachers need to push for more and better collaboration. No longer can teachers just teach what they enjoy, or pretend teaching is mostly improvisational. If we are truly professionals, we need to do serious work around our new standards and curriculum, including critiquing the teaching of colleagues, reviewing and refining lessons over time, and recognizing the body of knowledge about teaching mathematics that can be built upon and further contributed to. But listen for yourself.

NCTM Denver 2013: Abels, Matassa, & Johnson's Making Sense of Algebra with Realistic Mathematics Education

Annual Meeting - Thursday, April 18, 2:45 pm

Mieke Abels - Freudenthal Institute for Science and Mathematics Education, University of Utrecht
+Michael Matassa Jr. - Freudenthal Institute US, University of Colorado Boulder
+Raymond Johnson - Freudenthal Institute US, University of Colorado Boulder

When it came time to propose session for the 2013 NCTM Annual Meeting in nearby Denver, we at the Freudenthal Institute US at CU-Boulder knew we should have some kind of "Intro to RME" workshop. Because I was already proposing to be a lead speaker on another session, I needed to find someone else to take the lead. Michael Matassa said he would do it, but then +David Webb had a better idea: Why not ask Mieke Abels from the Freudenthal Institute to do it? Mieke would be a perfect choice - she's been involved in FIUS from the beginning and she continues to be involved in curriculum development for Mathematics in Context and curriculum in the Netherlands. Happily, Mieke agreed and Michael and I were happy to back her up as co-presenters.

The picture at the top is Nederland, CO, which is amusing to our Dutch colleagues

Our goal in this presentation was to bring out the curriculum design features and give attendees a sense for informal and preformal approaches to algebra for the middle grades. Too often it seems "early algebra" gets interpreted as "algebra early," as if a school could just box up their high school algebra textbooks and ship them down to the middle school. Making big jumps to formal mathematics is risky, and that's one reason Realistic Mathematics Education (RME) adheres to a principle called progressive formalization. To illustrate, we started with a task you could give to 6th graders, or perhaps even younger students.

Tug-of-war, taken from Mathematics in Context

Those of us who have mastered formal algebra tend to want to write equations for this and solve. But for young students, RME design principles suggest we support students by relying on a "realistic" context. While "real-world" contexts are certainly realistic, RME's use of "realistic" means it can be imagined by the learner. The power of the context is not necessarily its authenticity, but its capacity to be mathematized.

On the tug-of-war task students will inevitably find different ways to substitute different animals for each other until it becomes clear which side would win the tug-of-war. Some students will likely try to redraw the animals, while others might use letters ("E" for elephant, etc.) as a substitute. Even though a formal equation might use "E" to represent the pulling strength of an elephant, it's fully expected at this stage for students to try writing things like "E = O + 2H" to represent the animals in the middle of the above slide, and interpret "2H" simply as the abbreviation "2 horses."

The Iceberg Metaphor

The concept of progressive formalization is often represented with the iceberg metaphor (Boswinkel & Moerlands, 2003; Webb, Boswinkel, & Dekker, 2008), which places formal mathematics above the water line. The tip of the iceberg is only supported because of the iceberg's "floating capacity, which is where informal and preformal mathematics is placed. Examples like the tug-of-war problem are informal because they rely almost entirely on the realistic context with little or no mathematical abstraction.

Here's another example of an informal task:

Three Frogs, taken from Mathematics in the City

Again, the frog jumping doesn't have to be something replicable in the real world. It need only exist in the imagination of the student, and to solve it students need to find ways to represent the jumps and steps in their work. At this point students will have worked often with number lines (including open number lines) and easier problems involving frog jumping, making number lines a natural model for this problem, like this:

Using an open number line to represent Sunny's jumps

The nature of this problem and the need to draw double number lines that end in a particular place helps students consider what it means to be variable in this problem, versus what quantities remain constant. Other types of problems with other contexts use other kinds of models. For example, the familiar model of a balance is used in RME-based curricula (the 1 and 5 represent weights):

The balance model, found in the Digital Mathematics Environment

Student work for these kinds of tasks can be an indicator of where in the formalization process students might be. If students are redrawing pineapples and lemons, they are still working at an informal level. For convenience they might replace pineapples and lemons with letters, suggesting a small amount of formalization, and eventually they'll be using those letters to write equations and not need to think in terms of the fruit and the balance. Just like tug-of-war, the balance model suggests an understanding of equals that is relational, which helps students who tend to interpret equals as operational.

The use of models is at the heart of the preformal level of the iceberg. Nearer the bottom we would place models of informal contexts. For example, a student who draws sectors of a circle to represent a fraction of a pizza is using the circle as a model of the pizza. Nearer the top of the preformal level we would place models for mathematical abstraction. The student who uses sectors of a circle to represent a fraction of seats occupied in a bus is using the sectors of the circle as a generalized representation of a part and whole, and not a specific representation of a bus. In RME students become familiar with many models, such as number lines, open number lines, double number lines, ratio tables, five frames, rekenreks, area models, and balance models.

Models are key at the preformal level of the iceberg

Another preformal model useful for systems of equations is notebook notation. Here a problem shows two combinations of long and short candles. Working informally, students would find some combination of candles that makes the problem solvable, such as doubling the second combination to make two long candles and two short candles for $6.80. Since the top arrangement has one more short candle and is a dollar more, then short candles must cost $1.00. A preformal way of working with these combinations is notebook notation:

Notebook Notation, taken from Mathematics in Context

From the notebook it becomes easier to see how students will learn to write and manipulate formal systems of equations. The column headings become the variables, and equal signs are placed in front of the total. Formal matrix notation is reachable from notebook notation as well.

Although progressive formalization is often presented as a direct informal-to-preformal-to-formal process, it is not expected that students will learn this way. Students who can work formally or preformally with easier problems are likely to reach to a lower level when problems become more difficult. Because they have achieved the formalization with easier problems, they become more likely to formalize more difficult problems when they can reason with less formal strategies when necessary.

Another way to view progressive formalization is with a learning trajectory, which connects specific contexts and representations along a path towards formal mathematics. Creation of both iceberg models and learning trajectories can be a productive activity for professional development and curriculum planning and alignment.

A learning trajectory for equations and systems of equations, with connecting links

RME isn't meant to be deeply complex, but contexts, models, and the connections between them need to be carefully chosen. Curriculum developers at the Freudenthal Institute take a design research approach to this work, testing and revising in iterative cycles to improve the curriculum over time. FI (formerly IOWO) was founded by Hans Freudenthal in 1971, giving the Netherlands over 40 years to gradually improve their mathematics curriculum and teaching. This type of adherence to a core philosophy for so long is generally unknown in education in the U.S., but schools in the Netherlands have used it to score near the top of international rankings on the mathematics portion of the PISA assessment.

If you'd like more information about RME, the following might be of interest:
References

Boswinkel, N., & Moerlands, F. (2003). Het topje van de ijsberg [The top of the iceberg]. De Nationale Rekendagen, een praktische terugblik [National conference on arithmetic, a practical view] (pp. 103–114). Utrecht, The Netherlands: Freudenthal Institute. Retrieved from http://www.fisme.science.uu.nl/publicaties/literatuur/5467.pdf

Van Reeuwijk, M. (2001). From informal to formal, progressive formalization an example on “solving systems of equations”. In H. Chick, K. Stacey, J. Vincent, & J. Vincent (Eds.), The future of teaching and learning of algebra: The 12th ICMI study conference (pp. 613–620). Melbourne, Australia. Retrieved from http://repository.unimelb.edu.au/10187/2812

Webb, D. C., Boswinkel, N., & Dekker, T. (2008). Beneath the tip of the iceberg: Using representations to support student understanding. Mathematics Teaching in the Middle School, 14(2), 110–113. Retrieved from http://www.nctm.org/publications/article.aspx?id=20793.

NCTM Denver 2013: Johnson & Thomas's Statistical Reasoning in the Middle School

Annual Meeting - Thursday, April 18, 1:00 pm

+Raymond Johnson (Me!) - University of Colorado Boulder and Freudenthal Institute US
+Susan Thomas - University of Colorado Boulder


My colleague Susan Thomas and I took an interest in middle school statistics during our first year in our PhD program. When we read the statistics standards in the Common Core State Standards (CCSSM) for middle school, we both thought they were a major shift from prior standards, and we wondered how teachers would perceive them. For our qualitative research project, we found two willing middle school teachers who offered us access to their classrooms and time for interviews. The data we collected suggested that these teachers, both well-educated and in a high-achieving school, had some difficulty interpreting some of the standards, were unclear about some of the bigger ideas those standards might lead to, and did not have curriculum to support the level of thinking and reasoning called for in the CCSSM.

The push for more statistics is reflected in each iteration of major standards documents (NCTM 1989, 2000), the GAISE report, and the CCSSM. Some of this comes from the relative youth of statistics as a field. I've heard teachers say, "Why do we teach boxplots? We didn't learn them when I was in school," not realizing that John Tukey didn't invent them until the 1970s -- in many cases, the teachers are older than the plots. How often as math teachers do we get to teach anything younger than we might be?

More obviously, the push for statistics is part of the explosion of data in our world. Google's Eric Schmidt recently claimed that "There were 5 exabytes of information created between the dawn of civilization through 2003, but that much information is now created every 2 days, and the pace is increasing" (Kilpatrick, 2010). Even when the topic isn't "big data," increasingly we collect more and more information about our own activities. Making sense of data requires statistical thinking and reasoning.

To understand statistical reasoning, it's helpful to have a way of thinking about how statistics is different from mathematics. In 1962, John Tukey wrote, "Statistics is a science in my opinion, and it is no more a branch of mathematics than are physics, chemistry, and economics; for if its methods fail the test of experience -- not the test of logic -- they are discarded" (pp. 6-7). A more recent and helpful perspective of statistics comes from Michael Shaughnessy, who said "The twin sister of the 'certainty' in mathematics is the 'uncertainty' in statistics. We must prepare our students to deal with both types of quantitative reasoning as they grow in the mathematical sciences" (2010).

So what is statistical reasoning? According to delMas (2004), statistical thinking is knowing when and how to apply statistical procedures, while statistical reasoning explains why results were produced or why a conclusion is justifed. That means that things like stating implications, justifying conclusions, and making inferences are all part of statistical reasoning.

For this workshop, the strategy Susan and I used was to: (a) identify in each grade level of the middle school CCSSM a theme related to statistical reasoning, (b) find something in the research literature that might help teachers better understand what kind of reasoning to elicit and look for in their classes, and (c) evaluate some statistical tasks for their ability to elicit that reasoning. Susan got snowed out on the wrong side of Vail Pass, but thanks to our preparation together I was able to soldier on without her.

Grade 6: Variability and Distribution


A look across 6th grade standards

When we looked at the 6th grade standards, we saw a common theme of reasoning with variability and distribution. Yes, there's focus on measures of center and procedural things like knowing how to calculate the IQR and MAD, but all that is supported by reasoning with variability and distribution.

The work of Bakker and Gravemeijer (2004) stuck out to me in how they approached student reasoning with variability. "An underlying problem is that middle-grade students generally do not see 'five feet' as a value of the variable 'height,' but as a personal characteristic of, say, Katie" (Bakker & Gravemeijer, 2004, pp. 147-148). The suggestion was for students, instead of always assembling data points into distributions, had opportunities to deal with distributions that obscured individual points. By focusing more on distributions and variability, students will be more prepared later to reason with standard deviations, margins of error, and other topics in high school and beyond.

The tasks we chose to inspect were:

Often the best part of leading a workshop is simply giving teachers time to talk and share ideas. If you look at the tasks and want to share ideas, please do so in the comments.

Grade 7: Sampling and Inference


A look across 7th grade standards

Across the 7th grade standards we see a strong theme for reasoning with sampling and inference. The focus on informality here is key, as a standard like 7.SP.B.4 is not trying to suggest hypothesis testing and t-tests, but instead a basic understanding for how variability in samples indicates uncertainty about population parameters, either as a single sample or in a comparison of samples.

Two items from the research stood out to me here. First, Rubin, Bruce, and Tenney (1991) claimed that "Over-reliance on sample representativeness is likely to lead to the notion that a sample tells us everything about a population; over-reliance on sample variability implies that a sample tells us
nothing" (p. 315). Getting more specific about the notion of sampling variability, Saldanha and Thompson (2003) found that higher-performing students "developed a multi-tiered scheme of
conceptual operations centered around the images of repeatedly sampling from a population, recording a statistic, and tracking the accumulation of statistics as they distribute themselves along a range of possibilities" (p. 261). Together with reasoning of variability developed in 6th grade, these standards address the crux of inferential statistics: sampling distributions.

The tasks we inspected were:
There was a lot of good discussion about the Counting Trees task and speculation around student strategies. There's a clear intersection here with students' reasoning with ratio and proportion, and one teacher suggested instead of using the diagram in the task, using aerial or satellite photography with real trees. The key idea, however, is giving students opportunities to sample in different ways and reason why different approaches yeild different, yet similar estimates for the population.

Grade 8: Covariation


A look across 8th grade standards

The clear unifying theme across 8th grade CCSSM standards is covariation of two variables. There is some real opportunity to have this support 8th grade algebra standards related to graphing lines and linear equations, and I'm anxious to see curriculum that really ties the two together.

From the research, I noticed two key things. First, Konold (2002) judged that "It seems unwise, for example, to specify ... that by middle school, students will learn how to 'make conjectures about possible relationships between two characteristics of a sample on the basis of scatterplots' (NCTM 2000, p. 248)" (p. 5). Konold isn't saying that 8th graders can't understand scatterplots, but rather that middle school students understand covariability in a variety of ways, and will develop their own alternative representations before reasoning with scatterplots. In similar work, Moritz (2005) found that students with incomplete understanding will often focus on the variabilty of one variable but not the other, or the variability of both without the association between the two. Some examples of alternative representations:

An informal and creative bivariate table

Paried and sorted case value plots

Scatterplot slices

All of the above are non-scatterplot examples that appropriately show reasoning with covariation. The tasks we inspected that deal with covariation included:
We ran short on time for much of a discussion on these tasks, but participants were looking at how scatterplots were used and thinking about how else students might reason with covariation. Of course, none of the tasks used in the session were meant to be perfect, and none teach themselves. Instead, it's important to find the most promising tasks we can, understand them as part of a greater curriculum, and attend to the student thinking and reasoning they might elicit.

Lastly, here are the resources we recommended at the end of the workshop. By no means is this an exhaustive list. It's just a place to start for teachers looking to supplement or revise their curriculum.
(Link to our presentation, source files, and handouts.)

References

Bakker, A., & Gravemeijer, K. (2004). Learning to reason about distribution. In D. Ben-Zvi & J. Garfield (Eds.), The challenge of developing statistical literacy, reasoning and thinking (pp. 147–168). New York, NY: Kluwer.

delMas, R. C. (2004). A comparison of mathematical and statistical reasoning. In D. Ben-Zvi & J. Garfield (Eds.), The challenge of developing statistical literacy, reasoning and thinking (pp. 79–95). New York, NY: Kluwer. doi:10.1007/1-4020-2278-6_4

Kilpatrick, M. (2010, August 4). Google CEO Schmidt: “People aren’t ready for the technology revolution”. Readwrite. Retrieved from http://readwrite.com/2010/08/04/google_ceo_schmidt_people_arent_ready_for_the_tech

Konold, C. (2002). Alternatives to scatterplots. Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Teaching Statistics (pp. 1–6). Cape Town, South Africa: International Association for Statistical Education. Retrieved from http://www.stat.auckland.ac.nz/~iase/publications/1/7f5_kono.pdf

Moritz, J. (2005). Reasoning about covariation. In D. Ben-Zvi & J. Garfield (Eds.), The challenge of developing statistical literacy, reasoning and thinking (pp. 227–255). New York, NY: Kluwer. doi:10.1007/1-4020-2278-6_10

Rubin, A., Bruce, B., & Tenney, Y. (1991). Learning about sampling: Trouble at the core of statistics. In D. Vere-Jones (Ed.), Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Teaching Statistics (pp. 314–319). Voorberg, The Netherlands: International Statistics Institute.

Saldanha, L., & Thompson, P. (2003). Conceptions of sample and their relationship to statistical inference. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 51, 257–270.

Shaughnessy, J. M. (2010). Statistics for all -- the flip side of quantitative reasoning. NCTM Summing Up. Retrieved from http://www.nctm.org/about/content.aspx?id=26327

Tukey, J. W. (1962). The future of data analysis. The Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 33(1), 1–67.