NCTM Denver 2013: Thoughts on Mayim Bialik's "The Power of Just One Teacher"

Mayim Bialik, known mostly for her role as Amy Farrah Fowler on The Big Bang Theory, gave the opening talk at this year's NCTM Annual Meeting & Exposition. I must admit that having just spent 48 hours listening to research talks, I was a little relieved to be able to just sit back, leave my notetaking devices in my bag, and listen.

Mayim Bialik

I wasn't expecting anything deep and ponderous; after all, this is typically a time for cheerleading and celebrating the teaching of mathematics. (In contrast, consider the tone with which the researchers kicked off the pressession.) Two parts of the talk I especially liked. First, Bialik is outspoken in her support for public schools. Her parents were public school teachers and she was educated in public schools, even though she needed a private tutor at times when she was busy acting as a child. Second, a lot of good, interesting, and fun things came out of the Q&A she did after her talk. For example, she admitted her struggles with calculus and organic chemistry in college, but she was able to perservere to get past that on her way to a PhD in neuroscience.

If there was a part I didn't like, it was that she talked about Texas Instruments for a few minutes too many. Yes, I understand that she's a spokesperson for TI, but there was a moment there when I thought the promotion was starting to take over the talk.

I was interested in hearing Bialik's responses to questions regarding women in science. She emphasized the need to see strong female examples in STEM fields, even when those examples might be fictional, like her character on The Big Bang Theory. That's not a bad answer, but I think at this point my more critical and feminist-thinking colleagues have tuned my ears to mentions of identity development and "disrupting hegemonic power structures" in conversations like this. Perhaps her next talk could be titled, "The Power of Just One Teacher in a Professionalized, Adequately Resourced Education System." I won't hold my breath waiting for that, but that's a conversation that needs to keep happening.

Still, I like the idea that a lot of teachers at this conference are going to return to their classrooms tomorrow and excite kids with their stories of seeing Amy Farrah Fowler. You can watch Bialik's talk for yourself on the NCTM website: http://www.nctm.org/conferences/content.aspx?id=36436. Jump to about 19 minutes in to see Bialik's introduction.

NCTM Denver 2013: Kosko's Piloting Online Professional Development for Facilitating the Common Core

Research Presession - Wednesday, April 17, 3:00 pm

Karl Kosko - Kent State University

As part of an interactive paper session, +Karl Kosko presented on efforts to use online tools in professional development around the Common Core Standards for Mathematical Practice. This work is likely still in its early stages, so the research presented involved the participation of five teachers and the first practice standard, "Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them." Using LessonSketch, teachers observed an animation of a classroom and could "pin" moments related to that practice.

Following the viewing of the animation, teachers' homework was to work the practice into an upcoming lesson. Finally, teachers reflected on the lesson in an online forum. Kosko was able to find interpretations of the standard that ranged from "vague" to "emerging" to "clear," but further details were somewhat limited by the short duration of the professional development.

Kosko suggested that more work needs to be done to transition teachers' emerging interpretations of the standard to clear interpretations. Despite some teachers marking almost everything as an example of the standard, there was an indication that using pins to mark examples of the practice was an effective strategy for developing an understanding of the practice standard, and the homework connecting the PD to teachers' classroom practice was essential.

NCTM Denver 2013: Remillard et al's Using Curriculum Materials to Design and Enact Instruction

Research Presession - Wednesday, April 17, 1:00 pm

Janine T. Remillard - University of Pennsylvania
Ok-Kyeong Kim - Western Michigan University
Luke Reinke - University of Pennsylvania
Napthalin A. Atanga - Western Michigan University
Joshua Taton - University of Pennsylvania
Dustin O. Smith - Western Michigan University
Hendrik Van Steenbrugge - Gent University
Shari Lewis - Aquinas College

This group, composed mostly of scholars from the University of Pennsylvania and Western Michigan University, reported on the findings of their ICUBiT project. The project, "Improving Curriculum Use for Better Teaching," has the goal of better understanding how teachers interact with their curriculum materials to design instruction. Using Brown's (2009) concept of pedagogical design capacity, the study looked at teachers using five different elementary curricula and assessed teachers' knowledge of the mathematics embedded in curriculum materials. The five curriculum were Everyday Math, Investigations, Math in Focus, Math Trailblazers, and Scott-Foreman.

Using interview data, curriculum logs, video recordings, field notes, pre-observation check-ins, and two teacher content knowledge assessments, the group looked for teacher actions and understandings related to transitions from the written to intended and intended to enacted curriculum (Stein, Remillard, & Smith, 2007). This was also related to fidelity of curriculum implementation and in-the-moment decision making.

Ok-Kyeong Kim discussing fidelity

Effort was put into understanding how each curriculum presented curriculum materials and how that affected what teachers read. Many used visual markers, putting answers in a different text color, and tips in special boxes. This led into a discussion of teachers' ability to identify the mathematical point of a lesson and then steer children in that direction. Using the framework of Sleep (2012), the group coded how mathematical points were defined, linked to, explained, decomposed, etc. You can get a small sense for the coding in this picture:

Part of a coding scheme for mathematical points

The group listed some of the factors that influence fidelity of implementation, like the student, policy, mathematical goals, content, situation, teacher experience, resources, and whether teaching was seen to be driven by curriculum or teacher knowledge. For this work they focused on influences related to the student, the mathematical goals, the curriculum, and teacher knowledge. A question in the Q&A asked about the influence of standards, and Remillard admitted that was an area that needed to be investigated.

Near the end of the presentation the team displayed some interesting "lesson maps" that help show the work of teachers and where they do curriculum design work. The graphs show the use of tasks across time in a lesson, the origin of the task, and ties to the mathematical point of the lesson.

A lesson map highlighting design decisions

In closing, Remillard cited a need for digital and "fluid" support for curriculum use. Static help in teachers' guides are limited in their ability to guide instruction, and "It seems sometimes that putting text in its own box is an invitation to not read it."

References

Brown, M. W. (2009). The teacher-tool relationship. In J. T. Remillard, B. A. Herbel-Eisenmann, & G. M. Lloyd (Eds.), Mathematics teachers at work (pp. 17–36). New York, NY: Routledge.

Sleep, L. (2012). The work of steering instruction toward the mathematical point: A decomposition of teaching practice. American Educational Research Journal, 49(5), 935–970. doi:10.3102/0002831212448095

Stein, M. K., Remillard, J. T., & Smith, M. S. (2007). How curriculum influences student learning. In F. K. Lester (Ed.), Second handbook of research on mathematics teaching and learning (pp. 319–369). Charlotte, NC: Information Age.

NCTM Denver 2013: Boaler's Using Research to Make a Difference

Research Presession - Plenary Session - Wednesday, April 17, 10:30 am

Jo Boaler, Stanford University

"I think math is the subject with the greatest gap between what we know works from research and what happens in classrooms."

Jo Boaler used her plenary session as a plea to the research community to not only do good work with their research, but to find ways to make it more shareable. "New knowledge is not enough," says Boaler. As part of a presentation she made at ICME in 2006, she surveyed teachers from countries around the world, asking, "What research study has made the biggest impact on your practice?" She found that in the Netherlands, the Freudenthal Institute has a huge impact in classrooms, and the Centre for Research in Pedagogy & Practice has a similar impact in Singapore. But often in other countries, including the U.S., teachers often cannot tie any of their practice to an influential body of research.

That doesn't mean that U.S. research hasn't had an impact on practice. When Boaler asked math ed researchers, Jeremy Kilpatrick pointed to Cognitively Guided Instruction (CGI) for having a long history of helping elementary teachers and their students. Boaler found other examples, but they were all from elementary. She suspected that elementary teachers are both eager to learn about students' mathematical learning, and they recognize the enormous capacity for learning they see in elementary students.

Boaler pointed out one of the tensions of sharing research: Just as we know students don't learn simply because we tell them something, teachers don't learn simply because we hand them a journal article. "I am really sure that teacher learning, one thing about it, needs to be generative and we need to be giving teachers things they can take back to their classroom and continue to learn from." Boaler also recognized doing research in partnership with teachers is probably the gold standard, both for identifying questions that are really important for teachers and working along side them.

Boaler stressed the need for "records of practice," including student work, curriculum materials, videos of classroom teaching, teacher notes, and assessments. "The most powerful impact I've had comes from showing these records of practice." As an example, Boaler showed a video of two classrooms in the same high school. The first classroom, as a result of the math wars, was a class that reverted from using IMP to a traditional approach. The teacher in the classroom is talking while they work out an example, and students sit quietly in rows. Engagement is passive -- at best, the students are listening. The second video Boaler showed was from a classroom down the hall. They were working a problem of a skateboarder spinning off a merry-go-round towards a wall, and the engagement in that classroom was much different. Before the students had solved the problem, the teacher stopped students to share their strategies. Students were active at the board and at their desks, questioning each other or reaffirming each others' strategies.

Using Research to Make a Difference

In the second part of her talk, Boaler used the metaphor of hedgehogs and foxes to describe a divide in the math education research community. Hedgehogs tend to look through the lens of one idea, while foxes are more interested in variety and looking across ideas. Jeremy Kilpatrick claims that mathematics education has an oversupply of hedgehogs, and it would be good for mathematics classrooms if there were more foxes in our field. (A chapter by Kilpatrick on this topic will be appearing in a book called "Vital Directions for Mathematics Education Research.")

Boaler then showed some of the successes and difficulties she's faced in her own journey as a researcher. Her book, What's Math Got to Do with It?, has brought focus to math education to a widespread audience. Boaler found herself talking on radio shows or in interviews for newspapers with people sharing their traumatic experiences as math students in traditional classrooms. Boaler also decided to reach out to press outlets, writing articles for newspapers, and was invited to speak with politicians about policies regarding math education. In those discussions, Boaler has found many opportunities to share the research of others, including the negative uses of timed tests and tracking.

Boaler shared difficulties related to her long-running scuffle with Jim Milgram and other mathematicians who strongly favor a more traditional form of mathematics. Boaler has told much of this story on her website, so I won't recap all of it here. She took this as an opportunity to thank people for the support she's received from so many people, and believes that while it's good to question and disagree, it's not okay to attack and attempt to discredit. There are, and likely will continue to be those in the math community who don't share visions for reform mathematics, as evidenced by this quote from Milgram: "Those of us who actually know the subject strongly believe that in order to improve outcomes we have to dramatically increase teacher knowledge of the subject, and that teachers need to more or less directly impart that knowledge to students." As a field we should work with people who want to cooperate and don't claim that some fields of research are inferior to their own.

Turning back towards ways we can improve math education, Boaler looked to new technologies for sharing research and records of practice. She's been working with Udacity and will be offering a course this summer called "How To Learn Math." The course will first be offered to learners, but she will be releasing a teacher version of the course. Boaler has recognized a lot of desire in the Silicon Valley community to improve the way we teach and learn mathematics, but they don't know the body of research in mathematics education to help make that happen. For example, Sebastian Thrun of Udacity once told her, "My friend Bill Gates tells me that algebra is the big problem for students in school." Boaler boldly replied, "Oh, Bill Gates, the math educator told you that, did he?" This opened a long conversation that exposed the curiosity of Thrun and others to find ways to teach math better, and the need to put the expertise of math educators in front of those who can drive change.

Photo courtesy of Rita Sanchez

Lastly, Boaler made four points for going forward and using research to make a difference:
  • Work harder and more intentionally to translate and communicate research to teachers and the public
  • Engage with different forms of media
  • Stand up to unethical behavior and academic bullying
  • Work as hedgehogs, foxes, and hedgefoxes to make math classrooms places in which all students thrive


NCTM Denver 2013: Saxe et al's Engagement in Mathematical Discussion: Linking Practices and Outcomes

Research Pressession - Wednesday, April 17, 8:30 am

Geoffrey B. Saxe - University of California, Berkeley
Maryl Gearhart - University of California, Berkeley
Ronli Diakow - University of California, Berkeley
Nicole Leveille Buchanan - University of California, Berkeley
Jennifer Collett - University of California, Berkeley
Bona Kang - University of California, Berkeley
Kenton De Kirby - University of California, Berkeley
Marie Le - University of California, Berkeley
Discussant: Deborah Loewenberg Ball - University of Michigan

This group from Berkeley presented their findings from the use of Learning Mathematics through Representations, or LMR. LMR is a research-based curriculum unit for the teaching of integers and fractions in the elementary grades. Despite only being 19 lessons long (at the time of their study), it carefully attended to students' definitions of number, unit intervals, subintervals, and early fraction sense. When compared to similar coverage by Everyday Math, LMR produced significantly higher learning gains at all stages.

I'd have been hard-pressed to take a worse picture than this.

The group did find variability in LMR results. After checking for curriculum coverage differences and not finding anything significant, they developed measures for both content and participation. The group found that communication was key, especially for the lowest-achieving students.

This research group also did intensive classroom observation and video collection. They looked at interesting teacher moves designed to disrupt student thinking in ways that elicited student protest, where students became motivated to express their understandings of concepts in ways that corrected the teacher's intentional mistakes. The group paid specific attention to the trajectory of student understanding about unit intervals. Over six weeks, with pre-, interim, and post-assessments, they showed how students' understanding of the fraction 8/7 grew (for most students) over time.

Saxe's anthropological approach to studying shifts in understandings over time add some theoretical nuance to this work, examining the semi-durability of ideas as they are reproduced and altered. This kind of detail is often lacking in research, but can provide some key insights about teaching and learning.

The Discussant, Deborah Ball, began her comments with "Wow." I think that says a lot. She commented on the project at a meta-level, about the project itself, and "being greedy," she asked questions about what else we can get out of this body of work. Ball appreciated the connectedness of the project, both to other projects and across the history of Saxe's work. She also appreciated how the work was situated across all aspects of instruction, including teaching, curriculum, and class discussion. Ball called the work "programmatic" in the ways it carefully broke down the issues of the study and carefully applied the right methods, the care taken with definitions, and the depth with which instruction was analyzed. Ball also asked about "correcting the teacher," wondering more specifically what they perceive that move/strategy to be, and how it might not fit into either direct or dialogic instruction. For her "greedy" questions, Ball asked:

  1. What are you learning about teaching?
  2. What are you learning about the challenge of "drop-in" curriculum?
  3. What are you learning about the assessment of student learning?
  4. What did you learn about who was talking in class? What were the relationships with social or identity markers? What are you learning about the use of problems that weren't situated in the real-world of the students?
  5. How can the rest of us learn how to do this kind of programmatic work?

To answer #4, the nature of the work and issues with Human Subjects precluded them from collecting demographic information about students. In the interest of time, the panel decided to take most of the other questions under considerations while allowing time for Q&A from the audience. The most interesting answer in the Q&A was in regards to the availability of the LMR curriculum. Saxe said they tried getting it published commercially, but commercial publishers want to sell K-5 series of textbooks, not a 19-lesson replacement unit. So instead, the group is planning to post all the materials online and make them free for teachers to use in their classrooms.