RYSK: Gutiérrez's (Re)Defining Equity: The Importance of a Critical Perspective (2007)

This is the eighth in a series of posts describing "Research You Should Know" (RYSK).

Do you ever find yourself talking about something, defending something, or promoting something when you suddenly realize you don't have a good definition of that thing?

In one way or another, I've been thinking about equity in math education ever since I was an undergraduate. I remember debating the value of "equality of opportunity" versus "equality of outcomes," and getting a sense for how the NCTM Standards prescribed a type of school mathematics for all students. Here at CU-Boulder, issues of equity and social justice are never far away. But what, exactly, do we mean by equity in math education? And why is it important?

Rochelle Gutiérrez focuses on issues of equity as an associate professor of mathematics education at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Even though she's been publishing on issues of equity for well over a decade, in 2007 she wrote a book chapter titled, (Re)Defining Equity: The Importance of a Critical Perspective. In that chapter, she argues why we need a definition of equity that gives teachers and researchers a clear sense of purpose.

When equity is loosely defined, it comes under attack from several directions. First is a belief that not all students can learn, and that mathematical proficiency has more to do with natural ability than with effort. The second threat to equity is a "deficit theory" towards groups of students that haven't had much historical success in mathematics, whether that deficit is seen as biological or cultural. The third threat to equity, says Gutiérrez, comes from within the research community itself: so many issues get covered under the umbrella of "equity" that few of them get the kind of focused attention they need, even while many agree equity is important. As Gutiérrez puts it:

Perhaps the lack of a clear definition is what contributes to a general consensus that equity is worth striving for, everyone having his or her own vision of what it means. However, having a poorly defined target means we are only sure we are moving toward it when, in fact, we are very far away. (p. 38)

Gutiérrez argues that we should leave behind the traditional "excellence versus equity" and "traditional versus reform" debates in favor of a new perspective: dominant versus critical. Instead of teaching mathematics that "reflects the status quo in society, that gets valued in high-stakes testing and credentialing, that privileges a static formalism in mathematics," (p. 39), we should be favoring critical mathematics, that which "squarely acknowledges the positioning of students as members of a society rife with issues of power and domination" (p. 40). This includes using math to examine social and political issues, to highlight perspectives of different cultures, and to challenge the view that mathematics is a static entity. Gutiérrez does not wish to create a dichotomy here -- in fact, she argues the importance of learning dominant mathematics because it can help students better understand and criticize the world.

With that perspective in mind, Gutiérrez defines equity. First, she warns not to confuse it with equality; whereas equity implies "justice" or "fairness," equality implies "sameness." Gutiérrez is *not* arguing that all students should experience the same instruction using the same materials, or that we should expect all students to have the same outcomes. Gutiérrez fully recognizes that, within any group, experiences and outcomes will vary, and that some students will have interests that lead them away from mathematics. That's okay. Instead, she says equity in mathematics should consist of three main parts:
  1. "Being unable to predict students' mathematics achievement and participation based solely upon characteristics such as race, class, ethnicity, gender, beliefs, and proficiency in the dominant language" (p. 41, emphasis original). To clarify, Gutiérrez says, "I contend that only when there is sufficient variation within groups and no clear patterns associated with power or status in society between groups can we conclude that this aspect of equity is being addressed" (p. 42, emphasis original). As for measuring achievement, Gutiérrez says we should use standardized tests (but not exclusively), because those are often the tools we use to grant power to individuals.
  2. "Being unable to predict students' ability to analyze, reason about, and especially critique knowledge and events in the world as a result of mathematical practice, based solely upon characteristics such as race, class, ethnicity, gender, beliefs, and proficiency in the dominant language" (p. 45, emphasis original). It's this aspect of equity that Gutiérrez uses to stress the critical aspects described above.
  3. "An erasure of inequities between people, mathematics, and the globe" (p. 48, emphasis original). Gutiérrez claims "This aspect of equity addresses the fact that having equal access to cultural capital and critical stances to society are necessary but insufficient conditions for change" (p. 48). While this aspect of equity is by far the most difficult to measure, and may not happen in our lifetimes, it should be the key goal of any long-term reform in mathematics education.
Gutiérrez closes her paper with this paragraph:

It might be the case that the first two aspects of equity must be addressed before we would see any changes in the third aspect. That is, students who gain both (1) dominant and (2) critical mathematics identities will lead to different kinds of mathematicians in the academy, thereby changing what counts as mathematics as well as how it is evaluated. The important thing to consider in this (admittedly simplistic) model is that neither the first nor the second aspects of equity are sufficient to redress injustices in the world. Students need to be able to do both -- be able to play the game of mathematics that is currently associated with power and intellectual potential, and be able to change the game of mathematics to serve a better society. (p. 49)

References

Gutiérrez, R. (2007). (Re)defining equity: The importance of a critical perspective. In N. S. Nasir & P. Cobb (Eds.), Improving access to mathematics: Diversity and equity in the classroom (pp. 37-50). New York, NY: Teachers College Press.

RYSK: Staples's Supporting Whole-Class Collaborative Inquiry in a Secondary Mathematics Classroom (2007)

This is the seventh in a series of posts describing "Research You Should Know" (RYSK).

In her book What's Math Got to Do With It?, Jo Boaler recounted her first contact with the math wars. A group of parents at a local school had organized against the adoption of reform textbooks, and were telling students that if they took the classes with the new books, they wouldn't be eligible for college. Apparently the parents had called admissions offices and asked a question like, "Would you accept a student who had not taken any math in high school but had just talked about math?" (Boaler, 2008, p. 33). Of course the colleges said no, and from that question and response parents based a claim about reform texts and college admission.

If we try to put angry politics aside for a moment, where did the parents in Boaler's story get the idea that reform math was all about talking about math? Certainly that thought was not a total fabrication. In fact, the learning theories that influenced much of the reform math movement led teachers and researchers to think about how to structure classrooms in ways that maximized learning, and that led to an attention to classroom discourse -- the teacher-student and student-student speaking and writing that happens in classrooms. By studying classroom discourse, we can gain key insights about what and how math is learned, and how our experiences and our environment affect that learning. (This, I believe, is not unique to reform classrooms -- all good math teachers and students pay careful attention to how we talk about and otherwise communicate mathematics.)

Megan Staples, a former advisee of Jo Boaler, is an assistant professor at the University of Connecticut specializing in mathematics education and classroom discourse. In her article Supporting Whole-Class Collaborative Inquiry in a Secondary Mathematics Classroom (2007), Staples takes on the challenges of being the teacher and supporting students in "collaborative inquiry." Instead of simply viewing collaboration as working in groups, or cooperating to complete a task, Staples says collaboration, "implies a joint production of ideas, where students offer their thoughts, attend and respond to each other's ideas, and generate shared meaning or understanding through their joint efforts" (p. 162). As for inquiry, Staples sees it as a way of "engaging with and making sense of the world" (p. 163), and applies the term to "both inquiry into mathematics and inquiry with mathematics" (p. 163). Finally, and perhaps most importantly, is how Staples defines learning mathematics itself. Using a situative perspective, Staples sees mathematics as a cultural practice, where "learning results from, and is evidenced by, student participation in both standard and disciplinary practices (e.g., justifying, representing algebraically) and an array of other practices of mathematical communities (e.g., questioning, communicating, informal reasoning)" (p. 163). With these conceptions of collaboration, inquiry, and learning mathematics in mind, Staples conducted a year-long observation and analysis of Ms. Nelson, a veteran, award-winning teacher known for her dedication to reform mathematics principles. The class Staples analyzed was called "Math A," a lower-track 9th grade class for students with a history of low performance in traditional mathematics classrooms.

Staples's analysis yielded two models for teaching that support student participation in class discussion. The first model describes the role of the teacher in a whole-class discussion, while the second describes how Ms. Nelson increases the class's ability to collaborate over time. I'll present Staples's findings in outline form, with attention to specific recommendations for teachers wishing to support collaborative inquiry in their own classrooms. (Be patient -- the original article is 57 pages long, after all.)

  1. Model 1: The teacher's role in supporting whole-class collaborative inquiry
    1. Supporting students in making contributions
      • Eliciting student ideas -- Instead of just asking questions like, "Why?" or "How do you know?," Ms. Nelson presses students to share with comments like, "Come on, I'm really interested, come on, you can do it" (p. 175), gave students adequate time to formulate explanations, and offered participation points as a reward for contributing ideas.
      • Scaffolding the production of student ideas -- Ms. Nelson helps direct struggling students to use multiple representations and models, such as number lines, graphs, diagrams, etc. The key, says Staples, is to provide structure for the mathematics without constraining how the students will work out the mathematics (p. 178).
      • Creating contributions - Ms. Nelson treated incomplete and incorrect contributions by students the same as correct ideas, saying things like, "Remember the idea is to go up and give us some good discussion...that helps the class move along regardless of whether it's right or wrong, it enables us to have good discussion" (pp. 178-179).
    2. Establishing and monitoring a common ground
      • Creating a shared context -- Ms. Nelson focused on creating shared contexts among students. This was accomplished by repeating of student statements and encouraging students to record and share their representations and ideas on the board.
      • Maintaining continuity over time -- Ms. Nelson emphasized a sense of purpose when asking students to contribute. She directed students with phrases like, "Come up [to the board] please. Ron says that there are more diagonal lines. That Oscar didn't put enough in" (p. 181). Ms. Nelson also gave students time to understand and add clarity to other students' ideas before introducing new ideas.
      • Coordinating the collective -- Ms. Nelson actively positions students to respond to each other. When a student, Jay, had difficulty explaining an idea and Ken raised his hand, Ms. Nelson asked, "OK, do you wanna explain some more Ken? Or do you have a question for Jay?" (p. 185).
    3. Guiding the mathematics
      • Guiding high-level task implementation -- Ms. Nelson selected tasks that were difficult enough to invite collaboration, but guided students in ways that avoided unproductive exploration. This sometimes involved recounting the steps students had taken to reach their current thinking or requesting new representations of ideas. Either way, the focus was on how the students were thinking about the problem, and not just giving hints for the next step.
      • Guiding with a map of students' algebra learning -- This is where Ms. Nelson showed her experience with mathematics and the learning of mathematics, knowing the "pressure points" (p. 190) where students needed to pay particular attention to the structure of the mathematics.
      • Guiding by following: "going with the kids" -- Ms. Nelson showed a willingness to let go and follow students' thinking and be flexible with the intended destination of the lesson.
  2. Model 2: The development of a community of collaborative learners
    1. The development of practices over time -- High school is a difficult time to introduce collaborative inquiry because students have longer histories with traditional mathematics and because classes meet for a limited time each day. Expectations need to be made explicit and modeled for students.
    2. The model -- Developing community is an iterative process involving tasks or strategies that Staples calls "cycle starters" (p. 196) that spur student participation, which elicits negotiation of meanings, which leads to student interpretations and understandings. From there the cycle can repeat and improve.
    3. Negotiation of meanings -- For example, early in the year students, when asked to explain, automatically assume they've given a wrong answer. Once this practice is established, students improve in the ways they respond to questions about their thinking.
      • Helping students make sense of practices -- Early in the year, Ms. Nelson would fill in commentary when students did work silently in front of the class, saying things like, "He is noticing a pattern over here" (p. 198). This modeled the practice of thinking aloud for the class and emphasized the value of sharing one's thinking.
      • Providing evidence for the value for learning -- When students struggled, Ms. Nelson encouraged them to stop and express what it was they were struggling with. Making mistakes became an acceptable part of doing mathematics so long as they became opportunities to learn and correct misunderstandings.
      • Negotiation of the joint enterprise -- Ms. Nelson explained early in the year that these students were doing to do mathematics differently than in the past, and that they didn't need the math dumbed-down just because they hadn't been successful before.
    4. Cycle starters -- Ms. Nelson included not only engaging tasks, but helped create a vision of how that task could be accomplished, sometimes by describing the expected collaboration but also by showing a video of older students collaborating and discussing how they worked together.
    5. Students' interpretations and understandings of practices -- From student interviews and surveys, Staples found that students interacted with each other during class either for social reasons or to make the class less boring. By the end of the year, students reported that working together helped them learn because of the opportunities to listen and respond to each others' ideas.
    6. Transforming a community's repertoire -- Ms. Nelson's effort to transform the way it does mathematics was an ongoing effort that lasted the entire year. The effort is a negotiation, where as the class built new experiences together they could reflect on what was working and adjust their practices in future lessons.

In her discussion, Staples focuses on how teachers support collaborative inquiry while maintaining their role. It is certainly possible for a teacher to ask students to share ideas or report strategies, but it takes extra effort to build that common ground where students analyze and evaluate each other's ideas. Defining this common ground is difficult and it will be different in every classroom, but it is up to the teacher to develop and maintain it throughout the school year. Teachers also must be mindful of the mathematics, even when "going with the kids." It takes a skillful teacher to subtly push the mathematics while keeping the class collaborative. Lastly, the teacher must maintain a sense for a "long-term trajectory of student learning" (p. 210), although having such a sense does not necessarily support collaboration by itself. Staples's research is thorough and well-grounded in qualitative methodology, but it is not without its criticisms. I see critiques coming from two directions: from a more cognitive perspective, Staples doesn't attend much to individual student thinking, preferring to focus on social practices and classroom norms for participation. From a more purely sociocultural perspective, Staples doesn't account for how the influence of other, beyond-the-classroom cultures and community norms affect how students approach and understand mathematics. This is not to fault Staples, however -- she prefaced her findings with defining a situative perspective, and she maintained that perspective throughout. This just means that there are multiple ways of describing classroom communities and learning, and more work can be done to describe and build bridges across multiple perspectives.
References
Boaler, J. (2008). What’s math got to do with it? How parents and teachers can help children learn to love their least favorite subject (p. 273). New York, NY: Penguin Group.
Staples, M. (2007). Supporting whole-class collaborative inquiry in a secondary mathematics classroom. Cognition and Instruction, 25(2), 161-217. doi:10.1080/07370000701301125

RYSK: Boaler's Open and Closed Mathematics: Student Experiences and Understandings (1998)

This is the sixth in a series of posts describing "Research You Should Know" (RYSK).

The math wars might have quieted a bit since their heyday in the mid- and late-1990s, but if you hold your ear up to the internet and listen closely it won't be long before you hear the sound of reformists and traditionalists trading fire. A recent story in Education News by Barry Garelick triggered a battle in the comment section, bringing out many of the usual suspects to fight for the ground held by the other side.

While I might find such battles interesting (in a "straw-men-knocked-down-per-minute" sort of way), rarely do they accomplish anything but bolster the ill-will between the two camps. Occasionally there are hints at research findings, and perhaps somebody links to another story, blog, or website, but I never see much that might convince either side they might be wrong. Remember, this is the world of mathematics we're talking about, and "proving" anything right or wrong requires a standard of evidence not easily found.

Part of what sustains the math wars is the vast divide in what the two sides see as quality research and research methods, how they see the nature of mathematics itself, and how we measure success in mathematics[1]. A lot of math warriors might be willing to concede defeat if they came out on the wrong end of a large-scale, randomized, longitudinal experiment with high-fidelity implementations of reform and traditional curriculum and pedagogy, and multiple forms of assessment measuring a range of mathematical skills and abilities. But such experiments are very rare in social science – not because nobody wants to do them, but because the randomizing and controlling of people quickly veer towards the impossible and the unethical. So in the place of an idealized experiment, researchers have been trying to answer the traditional-vs.-reform question using the best methods available.

One such researcher is Jo Boaler. If I were to conduct a Family Feud-style survey of 100 math teachers, asking them to name a math education researcher, I'd expect Boaler to make it on the board. (Debating who else would be on the list might make for interesting Google+ and Twitter fodder.) Since earning her PhD in mathematics education from Kings College, London University in 1996, she has spent time in both the U.K. and the U.S. and is currently a professor at Stanford. While perhaps not as well-known as her later Railside study, her 3-year Open and Closed case study in the U.K. of two schools with traditional and reform approaches is worth examining here.

Boaler's research grew out of a concern that mathematical knowledge, when learned in a "traditional" way (which I'll define in a moment), isn't very transferrable to contexts outside the classroom. Learning transfer is a slippery subject for learning scientists to pin down, partly because we have a history of viewing learning as a cognitive ("in the head") activity, while transfer requires us to question the importance of our surroundings to what we learn, which is often referred to as situated learning (Lave & Wenger, 1991). Boaler wanted to investigate if, and how, being taught in mathematics affected future math performance in a variety of contexts.

For Boaler's study, she spent three years in two U.K. high schools, observing the daily activities inside mathematics classrooms. A great deal of the work was ethnographic, but she also conducted about 25 interviews per year, collected about 300 surveys, and administered a series of assessments. While the schools were not chosen randomly, they were in the same community, fed by the same primary schools, and had students with very similar demographic backgrounds. Test score averages for the two schools were roughly the same for students entering the 3-year study.

Math classes in "Amber Hill," the traditional school, generally consisted of a 15-20 minute lecture and working of example problems, followed by time for students to practice similar problems. Students were tracked into one of eight different levels depending on their prior test scores and teachers' judgment of their abilities. Overall, the atmosphere was described as calm and the students were motivated; in a short study of time-on-task, Boaler never observed fewer than 90% of students doing their work during the class. However, interview and survey data revealed that students found the work to be "boring and tedious" (Boaler, 1998, p. 45), and students described math as "rule following" (p. 46) and "cue-based" (p. 47), meaning students typically expected a task to indicate which rule to follow for solving a particular type of problem.

The other school in the study, "Phoenix Park," favored progressive education over traditional schooling. The atmosphere was very relaxed, and students were encouraged to accept responsibility for their own learning. Most of the math lessons were open-ended projects and students worked in mixed-ability groups. Boaler's description of the curriculum includes tasks like, "The volume of a shape is 216, what can it be?" When students needed math they did not know, they would get help from the teacher. When students lost interest, they were free to wander both physically and mentally in search of other work that might interest them. In the same short study of time-on-task, Boaler never recorded more than 70% of students working, and some students never appeared to do any work. When asked to describe their math lessons, the most common response from students was "noisy," followed by "good atmosphere" and "interesting" (p. 50). About a fifth of the students reported not liking having so much freedom in the classroom.

When comparing student attitudes in the two schools, Boaler found that Phoenix Park students reported being more interested in their lessons/projects, while Amber Hill students complained about their textbooks. At Amber Hill, boys reported being significantly more positive about mathematics than girls; at Phoenix Park there were no such differences.

One of the ways Boaler measured math performance was to give students a pre-test measuring their skills with volume and angles, then two weeks later give them an architectural activity using those same skills in context. A score of 1 represented a correct (or nearly correct) answer, while a 2 represented an incorrect answer. The percentage of students scoring a 1 on each task is shown in the table below.

Pre-Test
Volume
Pre-Test
Angle
Architectural
Task Volume
Architectural
Task Angle
Amber Hill72%94%55%64%
Phoenix Park60%94%75%82%

So while Amber Hill students scored better with decontextualized problems, Phoenix Park students did better with the tasks that more closely resembled using math in the real world. Boaler noticed a pattern in Amber Hill students' responses for the architectural angle task: many students took the word "angle" as a prompt to use trigonometry, even though none was needed.

While many might assume the traditional style of Amber Hill would result in those students receiving higher standardized test scores, Boaler suspected that transferring their knowledge from textbook to exam might be more difficult for Amber Hill students, as the exam contained questions that went beyond the simple application of rules and procedures. In examining GCSE exam scores from the end of Year 11, Boaler found 11% of students at both Amber Hill and Phoenix Park received an A-C grade, but 88% of Phoenix Park students passed the exam compared to only 71% at Amber Hill. Boys at Amber Hill received significantly higher grades than girls (20% to 9%), while no such significant differences were found at Phoenix Park (13% for boys, 15% for girls).

In the discussion section of the article, Boaler returns to survey data and exposes the differences in attitudes towards math among students from both schools. Amber Hill students admit that they didn't see connections between their textbook exercises and the real world, while Phoenix Park students talked more about the process of solving problems and using mathematics as an adaptable tool. In her conclusion, Boaler claims that while Amber Hill students knew more mathematics, the students from Phoenix Hill could apply more mathematics because their style of learning had forced them to become more flexible in their approach and more forgiving of their environment. Boaler does criticize the open approach of Phoenix Park because despite the relatively favorable test scores in comparison to Amber Hill, it led to a great deal of wasted student time. Regardless of the curricular and pedagogical details, Boaler's final conclusion is that "a traditional textbook approach that emphasizes computation, rules, and procedures, at the expense of depth of understanding, is disadvantageous to students, primarily because it encourages learning that is inflexible, school-bound, and of limited use" (p. 60).

Are Boaler's findings enough to end the math wars? If the answer was "yes," they would have ended in 1998 when the article was published. While the article does come across as a victory for reform, I don't think we can equate the progressive, open style of Phoenix Park with the expectation of "normal" reform classrooms. Similarly, Amber Hill might be more traditional than a "normal" traditional classroom. Still, Boaler's methodology helps shed light on how researchers try to answer the "traditional-vs.-reform" question, and this work helps us think about the importance of how we assess and how our perspective of learning changes when we view it through the lens of learning transfer. Boaler's conclusion should still be useful information regardless of your perceived approach, even if it falls short of declaring a cessation of hostilities.

[1] In addition, the lack of free public access to high-quality mathematics education research also sustains the math wars. After all, it's largely public opinion that keeps the war going, and researchers have allowed themselves to contribute to a system that discourages the public from seeing their published results. I'm hoping these posts put a dent in that knowledge gap, but I can only do so much. For a big step towards a long-term solution to this problem, I urge you to support HR 4004, the Federal Research Public Access Act, as well as http://thecostofknowledge.com/. Finally, something I think both the traditionalists and reforms can both get behind.

References

Boaler, J. (1998). Open and closed mathematics: Student experiences and understandings. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 29(1), 41-62.

Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation (p. 138). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Bonnie H. Litwiller, 1937-2012

I got word tonight that my undergraduate advisor, Bonnie Litwiller, passed away a couple days ago at the age of 74.

As a freshman at UNI, I had a temporary advisor until my program became more certain. After declaring as a math education major, Bonnie Litwiller was assigned as my advisor. I knew nothing about her. I remember asking Ed Rathmell, whom I had gotten to know while applying for a scholarship, what to expect from Litwiller as an advisor. I remember his response: "If you listen to her and do what she asks, she's great. She'll have your back when you need something. But don't cross her."

That's an uneasy way to know someone before you even get a chance to meet them. It felt like a description more fitting of mafia boss than a professor. But Rathmell's advice, as usual, was solid. Litwiller proved to be tough, and she made it clear to us that being a good math teacher was hard work. She set a good example: she and her research partner, David Duncan, would set aside a day a week where they'd lock themselves away in the library and write. As UNI isn't a top-level research university, the research activities of professors aren't always visible to the students. But Litwiller's dedication to research was clear, and there was no topic too small or journal too obscure. If she thought she had knowledge that would improve the teaching and learning of mathematics somewhere -- anywhere! -- she would write and submit for publication. She continued to write and publish even after her retirement from UNI in 2000, eventually passing the almost unfathomable mark of 1000 scholarly publications.

I took two classes with Litwiller, Teaching Middle School Mathematics and Teaching High School Mathematics. The classes were tough due to Litwiller being both picky about the quality of our work and her lack of clarity in describing what she wanted us to do. Some of us thought she was just being careless with her assignments, but I always wondered if this wasn't somehow purposeful. Either way, it was clear that she didn't want to do a lot of hand-holding. Some of us, ever so quietly yet respectfully, referred to her as the bulldog. A trusty companion that might just bite if you got out of line. If you didn't have the initiative and sense of responsibility to do quality work, I think she wanted a way for you to sort yourself out of the program. It happened, too; every semester some classmate would go missing and we'd try to find out what happened. Inevitably, someone would say, "They couldn't cut it. Litwiller dropped them from the program." You hear a lot today about colleges adopting GPA or test score requirements to improve the quality of their education majors. We didn't have those -- we had Litwiller. And just like letting a GPA decide who can be a teacher, I'm sure her judgement wasn't perfect and mistakes were made. (An acquaintance of mine, who shall remain nameless but now holds a PhD in math education, told me about a narrow escape from Litwiller's axe after a dispute over access to a local school.) But I think Litwiller had a sense for the quality that people expected from a UNI-prepared teacher, and a sense for giving us some survival skills that would get us through our first few years of teaching. There must have been far more successes than failures, too -- by the time I graduated in 1999, someone had estimated that a quarter of all the math teachers in the State of Iowa had been taught by Bonnie Litwiller.

My appreciation for Litwiller and her work has grown through my years first as a teacher and now as a graduate student in mathematics education. It was she who first introduced me to the NCTM Standards, and her direction of the NCTM Addenda Series was and still is an enormous contribution to the field of math education. What I believe was originally intended to be a six-book series to support the Standards grew into 22 total books, each designed to take the research behind the Standards and turn it into something teachers could use. Litwiller might have been the director and not the author of the Addenda Series, but it carried her trademark: getting as much useful information into the hands of teachers as possible. She gave me two books from the series, the middle school and high school books about statistics and data analysis. It was the first time I really thought about statistics education, and it's since become the area of school mathematics I find most interesting.

The world will miss Bonnie Litwiller, but she didn't leave without making a mark, both on the field of mathematics education and on me. Teacher education is a challenging business, and it's probably best to judge it with a certain amount of hindsight. For all of her toughness, she did have my back when I needed it, just as Ed Rathmell said she would. I may not have learned all that she tried to teach me, but maybe her most important lessons -- a sense of dedication and rejection of "good enough" -- have been most helpful in getting me to where I am today.

The Research Works Act and the White House OSTP

Imagine Company X proposed a law that said if they added value to a public highway -- such as by organizing volunteers to pick up trash on the side of the road -- then that gave Company X ownership of the road and the rights to charge the public tolls to use them. Sounds crazy, right? Well, replace "Company X," "public highway," and "pick up trash" with "Reed Elsevier," "publicly-funded research," and "peer review," respectively, and you've basically got the Research Works Act, a bill currently in the U.S. House of Representatives. If passed, the Research Works Act would prohibit federal funding agencies (such as the National Institutes of Health) from requiring that the research they fund (with your tax dollars) be available to the public. Instead, publishers could restrict access to any research they add value to (such as coordinating volunteers for peer review) for profit. Where does that profit come from? Usually from the high subscription fees paid by research universities, money often obtained from public funds and tuition dollars. The effect is that taxpayers are paying twice for research that, in many cases, they still don't have access to.

Fortunately, people are paying attention. Michael Eisen's op-ed in the New York Times explains the Research Works Act and its potential harm to research and scholarship, and plenty more articles on the subject are easily found. Somewhat coincidentally, we are also at the end of a feedback period for the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP), where they have made a formal Request for Information (RFI) about open access to scientific publications. Yes, the Research Works Act should be stopped and seen as little more than a request by for-profit publishers to continue having their work (along with their alarming profits) subsidized by tax dollars. But I don't think stopping one bill is enough. Instead, I hope to see all federal funding agencies adopt policies similar to those of the NIH. I expressed these hopes in an email today to the White House OSTP, the text of which I've copied below.



University of Colorado at Boulder
School of Education
249 UCB
Boulder, CO 80309-0249

January 12, 2012

To: Office of Science and Technology Policy
Executive Office of the President
725 17th Street Room 5228
Washington, DC 2050

From: Raymond C. Johnson, Doctoral Student in Mathematics Education
School of Education, University of Colorado at Boulder

Re: Response to the White House RFI on OA publications

I am a researcher, concerned citizen, and a supporter of open, public access to publicly-funded research. I speak for myself and not on behalf of my colleagues or my institution, although I believe I express ideas and opinions shared by many researchers and educators. In response to the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy request for information on “Public Access to Peer-Reviewed Scholarly Publications Resulting From Federally Funded Research,” I urge you to preserve policies that require public access (such as from the National Institutes of Health) and expand similar policies to other federal funding agencies such as the National Science Foundation, a key source of funding for education research in mathematics, science, and technology. Currently it is with great jealousy I see the growth of open access publishing in areas such as health and medicine; as an education researcher I wish I had the ability to share the latest research with teachers and administrators, most of whom cannot afford the high fees charged by publishers of education research. Unfortunately, open access journals in education are relatively rare and undervalued. A change in policy, one that would require public access to federally-funded research, would quickly change the perceived valuation of open access publishing outlets and bring much-needed information to educators everywhere.

Prior to my becoming a researcher I was a high school mathematics teacher for six years in high poverty, rural Colorado school districts. I did not have the benefit of a nearby university or a district support staff with access to recent or prominent research. My main link to information was a powerful one: the internet. However, it seemed that my searches for research about teaching methods, curriculum, education policy implementation, etc., all eventually led me to paywalls put up by publishers to “protect” their work, requesting fees I could not afford to pay. Now, as a researcher, I realize that the authors of education research -- much of it funded with federal dollars -- are asked to give their copyrights to publishers in exchange for so-called “widest possible dissemination” of that research. Researchers neither receive nor expect any pay or rewards for giving away their work, other than some scholarly esteem and the hope their research somehow reaches and benefits students and educators. While that publishing model might have made sense twenty years ago, it does not any more. Any claim of “widest possible dissemination” that currently does not include searchable, full-text publication on the public internet is false, at best, and fraudulent, at worst.

In response to the eight questions in the RFI, I encourage you to consider the arguments and recommendations made by Harvard University in their response (http://osc.hul.harvard.edu/stp-rfi-response-january-2012). Their expertise in these matters far exceeds mine. However, I do wish to make the following amendments to their responses for questions (2) and (7):

(2) What specific steps can be taken to protect the intellectual property interests of publishers, scientists, Federal agencies, and other stakeholders involved with the publication and dissemination of peer-reviewed scholarly publications resulting from federally funded scientific research? Conversely, are there policies that should not be adopted with respect to public access to peer-reviewed scholarly publications so as not to undermine any intellectual property rights of publishers, scientists, Federal agencies, and other stakeholders?

Harvard’s response refers to a need to divide and share rights between researchers and publishers. My recommendation beyond their statement is that any discussion of copyright include Creative Commons (http://creativecommons.org/), an organization dedicated to creating and defending content licenses that allow creators to reserve some, but not all, of their copyrights. Their expertise should be invaluable in any discussion about the sharing of intellectual property rights. The Harvard response includes a recommendation of a Creative Commons license at the end of their response to question 1. I also urge you to consider the expertise of SPARC (http://www.arl.org/sparc/), the Scholarly Publishing & Academic Resources Coalition.

(7) Besides scholarly journal articles, should other types of peer-reviewed publications resulting from federally funded research, such as book chapters and conference proceedings, be covered by these public access policies?

In Harvard’s response, they say they “could support mandatory public access” for non-journal works, but consider these to be “secondary issues” and are “not prepared to list all the types of content to which a federal public-access policy ought to apply.” I worry that this position is short-sighted and leaves too much room to abuse public access policies. Often the events that lead to research becoming a book chapter instead of a journal article are entirely matters of circumstance, and not a basis of quality or public importance. In fact, the entire distinction between article and chapter relates to a paper-based publishing economy, one that is increasingly irrelevant in a digital age. After all, if we were still limited to publishing on paper it is unlikely that this kind of public access policy discussion would even exist. If the spirit of these policies is to give the public access to research they have funded through federal tax dollars, there is no need to worry about “types of content” other than to say the research will consist of bytes and files traveling the internet. Furthermore, if the policy only requires “journal articles” to be published openly, what is to keep publishers from re-branding themselves as something other than a journal? By relabeling their products as books, magazines, or something entirely new, unwanted loopholes around public access are sure to emerge.